In our most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

When should one pull a book project from an unresponsive press? My editor at a major press has screwed up at almost every step of the process. For example, she failed to deanonymize peer review comments, which has hurt one of my professional relationships. After passing peer review in September, I have still not received a contract. Now she hasn't responded to my emails for months, since January (she is certainly still at the press). I asked to switch editors with no luck. I feel like I'm falling into the gambler fallacy at this point.

I'm really sorry to hear that the OP is dealing with this, as I know just how much work a book is and how invested in it one can be–and it seems unprofessional for an editor not to respond for so long. But if the editor hasn't been responding for months on end, I'm apt to think that the thing to do is to inform them that if you don't hear from them by some date X, you plan to move on.

What do readers think?

Posted in

4 responses to “When to pull a book manuscript from an unresponsive publisher?”

  1. Write to the editor in chief, stating the facts and not making any judgments. Then ask the editor in chief to look into the matter. A colleague recently did so after a similar delay from a series editor. The editor in chief looked into the matter and acted. The series editor is no longer with the press and my colleague’s book is now in the world.

  2. Greg Stoutenburg

    Years ago, I had a colleague from another university tell me a story like this. I asked who the publisher was. He told me, and I was able to share that I’d heard from someone who works for that publisher that the company is in the process of shutting down. He pulled the book, resubmitted it with Cambridge, had it published, and for a few months beers were on him.

  3. hmmm

    Do realize that if you pull your book from the Press they will not want to deal with you in the future. But you need to do something. Some time ago, there was a famous case of someone in a similar situation in a neighbouring field (not philosophy). And they had a senior colleague follow up on their behalf (VERY senior). It was discovered that the editor had a bad drinking problem, and had a whole cabinet full of unread manuscripts.

  4. Circe

    Sadly, this was my exact experience with the current philosophy editor at OUP, she too failed to respond to emails for months.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Philosophers' Cocoon

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading