In our new “how can we help you?” thread, a reader asks:

If a paper is taking a longish time (say, more than 3 months) at a journal, is there any point in sending an email inquiry as the author? I assume that the reviewers are being slow and that the editors are sending reminders. I also assume that there’s nothing the editors can really do to speed up reviewers that they are not already doing. Suppose I’m not considering retracting my submission (yet), is there any point in sending an inquiry?

I recall when discussing this in the past, readers suggested it can be reasonable to send an inquiry after 3 or 4 months. But, like the OP, I’m not sure whether there’s a point to it. Then again, I’ve also heard stories of papers getting “lost” at journals from time to time, so maybe it couldn’t hurt?

What do readers think?

Posted in

12 responses to “When to inquire about a paper under review?”

  1. I think it is perfectly reasonable—and sometimes helpful—to contact journals after waiting a sufficient amount of time. What counts as “sufficient” varies journal by journal. The Journal of Philosophy, for example, only provides reviewer reports after six months, so I personally would not reach out to them before then. More generally, if a journal says something like “we aim to get a decision to authors within X months,” I would wait until a while after X—perhaps another month—before inquiring.

    That said, I have found that inquiries can help. Once, I could see on the manuscript website that the reviewer reports had been in for a month. After I wrote to the editor, I had a decision within two days. I cannot be certain, but my best guess is that the reports had simply been sitting in a backlog, and the email nudged the editor to look them over. Quite recently, I reached out to another journal to ask for an update, and the editor replied that they had thought they had sent the reports some time ago, but a glitch meant that I never received them. In both cases, contacting the editor seems to have had a material effect.

    In other cases, an inquiry may not speed things up, but it can still provide peace of mind. I have received replies along the lines of: “We have one reviewer report in, and a second reviewer has just agreed; we hope to have a decision within two months.” That sort of response does not necessarily accelerate the process, but it does help set expectations.

    The main caution is not to reach out too early. For most journals, I personally would not inquire right at the three-month mark; that is still a fairly normal turnaround time. But once the review has gone noticeably beyond the journal’s stated or typical timeframe, I think a polite inquiry is entirely reasonable and can sometimes make a real difference.

    1. Anon

      I disagree. 3 months is the standard time to check in unless the journal says the try to get a decision in eg 4 months. It also helps because you can check to make sure the paper didn’t fall through the cracks. If it has fallen through the cracks, then less time is wasted.

  2. Anonymous

    It really depends. Some systems allow you to somewhat guess what’s going on. So, for example, if the paper remains a “new submission” like waiting to be assigned to an editor or something like that, it may be worth prompting after a month. The same for being assigned to editors, and not being sent to external reviews. Two recent publications of mine both advanced to the next stages after asking, including revisions not being sent out to reviewers and having all reviews in but no verdict after 1.5 months or so.

    Sometimes I get radio silence or immediate rejections though.

  3. AGT

    I am of the opinion that it is perfectly reasonable to inquire after 3-4 months. Most journals these days give us, as reviewers, a month or so to do the review, so the discrepancy is evident. While it is of course often the case that the reviewer is late and the journal might have complicated decision processes, this fact alone seems nonetheless sufficient ground to ask. Why not? In what sense would it be counterproductive? They will reject the paper because we dared to bother them? Hopefully, we are not there yet (and if a journal operates like this, one should not submit there, in my view). If the journal does not answer, well, so be it, but that is hardly a major damage…

  4. Corvus splendens

    Inclined to agree with the broad consensus of 3-4 months, plus or minus special cases where journals are known/advertise that they will take longer.

    Worries about reviewers taking longer than they ought shouldn’t come in to the author’s reasoning, I think, since a reviewer not reporting back is one of the things that an editor can realise upon being prodded and potentially do something about. (Anecdotally, the one time I chased and it became apparent that it was reviewer 2 blowing through their deadline that was the holdup, I received a prompt rejection on the basis of a single report. But, given that I doubt a second report would have saved me and could have taken ages longer either way, I considered this a good result once I’d stopped sulking.)

  5. It would be bad if we transitioned to a system where, in order to get any paper published, you had to bug the journal once, or twice, or three times, etc. This would be annoying for everyone involved. I worry that the “reach out after 3-4 months” norm helps move us closer to that sort of system, if only ever so slightly. It allows journals not to enact practices that catch papers that fall through the cracks, since they can just rely on the author to catch them. Journals can thus start letting more and more papers fall through the cracks without worrying this will mess things up too much.

    Probably my worry is silly. Journals are already in a position to treat authors however they want, so perhaps they’re indifferent between papers falling through the cracks or not. But maybe this is food for thought.

    With the exception of papers I’ve co-written, where my co-author wanted me to reach out, I think the only time I’ve ever reached out to ask about the status of a paper is when 1 year had gone by with no update from the journal. I have two papers coming up on the 1 year anniversary soon (in August) and I’ll probably reach out to ask about them. So, going by my own practices, I’d say wait a year before asking anything. But maybe I am being too stingy.

    For the record, here are some journals that got back to me after 3-4 months or more without any prompting on my part, such that my reaching out after 3-4 months would have been a waste of time for me and for them: The Journal of Value Inquiry, Analytic Philosophy, The Philosophical Quarterly, Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, Social Theory and Practice, the Journal of Philosophy, Philosophical Studies, Res Publica, Moral Philosophy and Politics, Hypatia, Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy, Thought, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, the Southern Journal of Philosophy, Philosophers’ Imprint, and Pacific Philosophical Quarterly.

  6. Anonymous

    I don’t share Daniel’s concerns to the same extent, although I also wouldn’t tend to write the journal after only 3 months. I have reached out to journals a few times about inordinate delays (5+ months usually) and each time, I received an apology/explanation that the paper had gotten lost at some stage or the journal was having organizational problems. So I’d conclude that the delay would have gone on significantly longer if I hadn’t reached out.

    I tend to be more patient about reaching out if it is the initial submission. If the portal shows that the paper has gone out to reviewers, I tend to just wait. I would be more likely to reach out if the paper had reached the 4-6 month mark without any recent updates in the portal. I’ve been more likely to contact the editor if the paper seems to have gotten stuck at a later stage in the process, particularly if it was not going back to review and just needed an editor decision or copyediting or whatever. In these cases I assume the issue is more likely to be that an editor or journal staff forgot something rather than waiting for referees to write back.

  7. Anonymous

    I remember a couple of times when, after waiting for a decision for longer than I expect, I bump the journal and hear from them about the decision very shortly. So yes, it could help. (It’s also unclear to me how it could even hurt?)

  8. Anonymous

    My paper has been under review at a journal for more than seven months. Although the journal promises to reach decisions within three months, I waited until six months had passed and then contacted the assistant editor. Over the subsequent weeks, I followed up both through the submission portal and via email, but I have received no response. Because the journal operates a triple-blind review, I am hesitant to write to anyone else on the editorial team. What would you recommend I do now without violating anonymity?

    1. Anonymous

      I guess you can always use some “hide my email” function when enquiring. Some smart phone companies provide this service, and one can always just create an anonymous email address just for this purpose. Write something like

      Sorry for enquiring via an anonymous email, but this is to not compromise anonymity. I am writing to enquire about [insert manuscript number], as it has been under review for [x years], and I have enquired separately for [y million times]…

  9. Anonymous

    This might just be a rhetorical question, but how difficult is it for journals to be a bit more transparent?

    I get it that some journals accept email submissions, and there’s no website for us to check manuscript status. But many journals now use some submission system, yet some are less transparent than others. Some journals are super transparent, like Ergo and JESP, where we can easily see what stage the manuscript is in, e.g. how many reviewers were invited on what date and whether they have agreed to review and when, if ever, they’ve submitted a review. Others seem to update the “status date” occasionally, but always just display “under review” from review invitation up until a decision is made, whereas a different journal under the same system can provide a bit more information like “editor invited” “editor assigned” “under review” “awaiting associate editor recommendation” “pending decision” etc.

    I get it, like journals are under no pressure to be transparent, and some may find it more difficult to upskill their admins to poke around the system to make things easier for us. But honestly just how difficult would it be to be a bit more user friendly?

  10. Anonymous

    May I ask when to contact again, if there’s a point of doing so? Thanks! A paper of mine has been with the journal for over 5 months. I contacted the handling editor two weeks ago and have got no response so far. I assume that it is the beginning of summer and everyone has things to attend to. I’m thinking about asking again in another two weeks (that is, one month after the first inquiry).

Leave a Reply