In our newest “how can we help you?” thread, a reader asks:

I am currently tenured at an R2 university in the US. I recognize I am fortunate relative to many peers, though I also understand that I will probably be stuck here forever if my program won’t be eliminated (fingers crossed). Nevertheless, I still wonder what some potential career possibilities remain open for me within philosophy and how I might pursue them, knowing that most of them will be very unlikely to happen?

For example, is publishing a ton at top journals the only way to make it possible to move to an R1? Given that my current position is teaching-intensive at the undergraduate level, what are practical strategies for carving out more research time? (Even more practically, would it be reasonable for me to not care too much about my teaching evaluations or pedagogical innovations but to spend more time doing my own research, if I would like to keep this possibility open?)

I saw some people did parallel moves from an R2 to another R2 (or lower end R1). How does this sort of career path happen? Would some administrative experience help?

I think I also saw some people moved from R2s to SLACs. In such cases, does research still matter most? Or does a strong undergraduate teaching record carry more weight?

I have already accepted the fact that I will be at my current job for a couple more decades. But knowing some potential ways to be out would still help me understand my situation better. Thank you for your input!

These are all good questions, and I’m not sure about the answers. I have worked at a SLAC for past 16+ years, but did receive an offer from an R1 last year (which I turned down). I’m not sure, but I suspect that publishing in some good places probably helped. At least anecdotally, my sense is that some tenured jobs are looking for people with various administrative & leadership experience, such as experience as department chair or leading public-facing university programming. But obviously, these are just some anecdotes.

Do readers have any helpful tips in response to the OP’s questions?

Posted in ,

One response to “Tips for moving to a new (type of) institution after tenure?”

  1. Anonymous

    I think that post-tenure moves are very difficult to make. And especially if you are seeking to “move up” in some way. I did manage to move from a 4 year college to a research university after tenure after many years.
    Administrative work/experience provides some opportunities for moving. But if a university hires you from outside to chair a department you are almost guaranteed that the department is messed up (that is, has some BIG problems). That is the principal reason for externally hiring a chair – the current faculty cannot solve some sort of problem, or get along with each other. And you will have to take on the role of the chair, at least for five years. So it won’t be an easier job.
    Setting that option aside, at the post-tenure level you not only have to publish in good places, your work has to be having an impact. That is part of the reason I got my current job – my work has more impact that anyone else in the department I now work in (and by no small measure). Incidentally, you have far more control on the amount you publish than you do on the impact of your research.
    Here is some advice (take it or leave it). Live your life like you will be at your current institution until you die. (and, as you note, you probably will be there until you die). And do things you enjoy. There are other career possibilities even if you stay at your current institution – you can go into administration. If you are good at it, you can make more money and even help philosophy, the discipline. I considered this option.
    But, if you are set on moving, look at the type of places you would like to move to, and see how the faculty there differ from yourself. If they all have three monographs with OUP and CUP, then get writing books.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Philosophers' Cocoon

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading