In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:
Reviewers ethics. Is it OK to recommend “reject” because the author is rude? I recently reviewed a paper and recommended “reject.” However, the editor chose R&R and I got the author's revised paper and their responses to my comments. I think the paper still sucks big time, so I would re-iterate my “reject” anyway, but… I gave a lot of unvarnished-but-not-uncharitable comments on the paper. In the authors response, they make a lot of remarks that I can’t read as other than rude, e.g. “It seems that reviewer 1 has utterly failed to grasp my point… Thanks for this strange suggestion, but no…..Wow thanks a lot for this wider remark, I’ll save that topic for my next book”.
When I’m dealing with students I don’t really get upset by rudeness/tactlessness, but I still react negatively, so that they learn how is appropriate to interact with professors, etc. Is that appropriate here?, to recommend reject and leave a note along the lines of “You should remember who is doing who a favor here and be more polite, my friend.”
Interesting question, and I'm curious to hear what everyone thinks. Personally, I don't think one should reject an author's paper because they are rude. After all, an author might be rude while their paper is excellent, and our task as reviewers is to evaluate the work submitted. But, of course, in this case the OP notes that they arrived at a negative evaluation of the paper anyway, so the above case is neither here nor there in this case.
It's another question, I think, whether a reviewer should comment on an author's rudeness in their reviewer report. Here, I'm note sure. But here's a thought: most journals allow authors to submit a review to forward to the author, but also private comments for the editors only. One option here is to indicate in one's comments to the editors that the author was out of line, and to request that they say something to the author. Then again, if an author is really out of line, then maybe it does make sense to say something in one's review to them.
What do you all think?
Leave a Reply