In our October “how can we help you?” thread, a reader writes:

I’m currently on a sabbatical working on a monograph. I specialise in the philosophy of language. My CV is decent; I published papers in TOP-20 Leiter-list journals, but not in the super-cool places like Nous or Australasian. I don’t have a fancy affiliation; I come from a country far away from Ivy League schools…

Is it worth trying to publish my book with OUP or CUP? I’ve checked what they actually publish, and there are almost exclusively people with big names and cool affiliations. It strikes me as a waste of time and energy to submit anything to those publishers, especially given that I was approached by a slightly less prestigious publisher (but still good; books published by this house are quite frequently reviewed in NDPR). They didn’t offer me a contract yet, but they seem interested in working with me on the book.

What do you think?

Not sure, but my general sense aligns with the OP’s.

What do readers think?

Posted in

10 responses to “From publishing in top-20 journals to a book with CUP or OUP?”

  1. Michael Kates

    If you don’t have a contract yet with the less prestigious, but still good, publisher, then what is the opportunity cost associated with sending your manuscript to OUP/CUP? The worst thing that could happen is that they reject it. But that won’t burn any bridges with the less prestigious press (since you don’t have a contract with them), and perhaps they might even accept it.

    (For what it’s worth, I don’t think you should assume that just because you don’t teach at a fancy school, you don’t have a shot of publishing a book at OUP/CUP.)

  2. Anonymous

    I published a monograph with OUP, and I am not a big name with a cool affiliation. One of my regrets for my first book is that I did not approach a university press because it would have made my tenure case a slam dunk. (The contract with OUP came as I was going up.)

    The worst that can happen is they say no. While sending it to them would require spending time to write a proposal (please don’t generate it with an LLM; publishers can spot that and dislike it), that time can be valuable anyway. In a proposal, you need to explain your book’s thesis, describe who would buy it, lay out the chapters you’d write, and situate the book in existing literature. That’s all valuable to think about. And you’d need to write a chapter or two, possibly the whole monograph, depending.

    If you do all that and they say no, you have reflected on the shape of your book and written material. But they might also say yes.

    There are guides online to writing such things (Laura Portwood-Stacer has some useful material, even though it isn’t specifically for philosophy), and there are professional editors who will help you with it, if you have some book funds, grant money, or are willing to spend your own money. Friends and colleagues who have reviewed these kinds of proposals are also good sources of feedback.

  3. Michel

    I have a few with OUP, and I am no kind of big shot, teaching at no kind of fancy place.

    One thing that makes me a little leery of OUP these days, however, is the cost of their books. It seems like over the last few years they’ve decided to only sell to libraries, and so pretty much every philosophy book they publish costs $100 or so, and that significantly reduces sales. I guess it must still make economic sense for them, as the publisher, but as an author, it doesn’t just mean smaller royalties (if any), it also means each book has much less impact.

    (Also worth noting that between the last EIC and with the shakeup of her replacement, things have slowed down a fair bit at OUP, and there’s a backlog they’ve been working through. This is less noticeable if you go through one of the societies that publish with OUP, like the British Society for the History of Philosophy, because they’re on the ball, but you’ll still stall a bit at the production stage.)

  4. Go for it!

    Lots of people who are not ‘big stars’ publish in these presses. In fact, I wonder if the OP is overstating the prestige of these presses. I’ve come across lots of OUP publications, for example, that to my eye is either sloppy or unnecessary.

  5. Anonymous

    I would think that the primary factor here is time. If you aren’t time pressed at all, then I guess you could submit everywhere, wait for a response, then move on. The process could last years, but if that’s not an issue, then I would agree with the “why not?” judgment, at least if certain presses mean more to you. If you’re keen to get the book out sooner rather than later, however, then you might moderate the number of places you submit to before you go with the publisher that you consider to be slightly less prestigious.

  6. Anonymous

    I’m sorry if this is a dumb question, but do publishers actually look at things like one’s institutional affiliation when deciding on a manuscript? I don’t know the process at all, so I’m curious (I’ve only published articles in journals). It seems odd to factor something like that into the decision-making process. One’s publication record seems more appropriate, but even so, I would have thought that this kind of decision is based primarily on the merits of the project itself. I am being naive?

    1. Anonymous

      You (and others reading) might want to look at some blog posts from a few years ago on this topic at The Splintered Mind and Daily Nous. A relevant quote from a publisher at Princeton University Press: “the reputation, credentials, and name recognition of an author are not insignificant factors in a publishers ability to promote and sell a book, so publication decision do have to factor these things in.”

      That doesn’t mean your affiliation will sell the book (or keep it from selling). It’s part of the whole package, including publication record.

  7. Anonymous

    In my experience (as a non-fancy person with publications in top journals):

    If you are not pressed for time, it is worth a shot. When I tried, the proposal was really the easy part: the real catch was that they wanted a complete manuscript (not just sample chapters) ready for peer review, and made me agree not to talk to other presses while the thing was under review.

    I screwed up by following the advice of some fancy friends (who got contracts with an unpolished chapter draft or two) and sent a draft of the book. They actually wanted a polished version of the manuscript: it was more like the peer review process for journal articles than the old proposal-draft chapter-contract scheme that worked for my fancy friends.

    Ultimately, I came close to getting in with one of those presses, but not quite. As a positive, I got some feedback that improved the book (which is now in press elsewhere). As a negative, the overall process took a very long time because I was not allowed to try other presses until they rejected it.

    For my next book, I’m going to try these guys again. Now I know that before I bother with a proposal, I need to be about two months out from a complete and polished manuscript, up to the standards of top journals in my area; a few chapters or a decent but unpolished draft is not going to work.

  8. Bill Vanderburgh

    Competition is high, so make sure you are putting together the best application package you can. The Book Proposal Book (Portswood-Stacer, PUP) is a very useful guide to how to get an academic book contract.

  9. Anonymous

    I have published three monographs and two edited volumes with one of these top presses. When I published my first book I was at a non-prestigious college. But I had published papers in top specialist journals. I first approached a different publisher, one less prestigious. I gave the commissioning editor a proposal and a few draft chapters. In one sense, that was a mistake. But she did read the material. In the end she said her Press was not publishing in that area any more. But she did recommend I send the manuscript to one of the big two presses. The editor at this second press (one of the top presses) was enthusiastic but made it clear that she would not issue a contract without a complete draft of the book. So you need to be patient. The time from my first meeting with a publisher (2008) until the book was finally in print with the better publisher (2011) was three years. And I had already been working on the book a year before that.

    Even with the second book, I did not get a contract until the editor had the full manuscript.

    Because I honour deadlines, am a careful worker, and am easy to work with, the commissioning editor subsequently asked me to edit two volumes in special series they were handling. These were nice projects to work on. I felt I got an opportunity to shape the way the sub-field was going. And it was an honour to work with the various people from whom I commissioned contributions (junior and senior).

    I have moved to a more prestigious university, and published another monograph, and have a fourth one in production. Every book faces challenges. So you need to be patient.

    Why publish with the Big two publisher? First, they generally produce high quality books – high quality in content and in production. Second, they spend a lot on production and editing, and this makes your book better. Third, because of their reputations, your book will be bought by libraries and many readers, or at least more than if you had published your book with a lower ranked press. Fourth, they will promote your book at conferences, and aim to have it reviewed in journals. Fifth, you will get royalties. Usually this is not a lot of money, but over the years I have made enough to enjoy a good meal out at a nice restaurant every few months.

    Further, it is an honour and privilege to work with the editors at these presses. They are professionals, and they know their business.

Leave a Reply