In our October “how can we help you?” thread, a reader writes:
What is the current opinion of Philosophy & Public Affairs? This is highly relevant to early-career folks who are deciding where to send papers, where they will be locked up for months.
My impression is that opinion is extremely split. Some people deem the new PPA as essentially unworthy of engagement beyond ridicule. But many others (especially judging by its acceptance rate remaining around 5%, according to the EIC in a recent DN thread) continue to think of it as a prestigious journal worthy of submissions. This seems to correlate strongly with background political views, with more lefty academics having the lowest regard for the new PPA.
I am trying to get a sense of whether my impression is accurate. To that end it would be helpful if folks could answer two questions. 1) When you see that an arbitrary article was published in the new PPA, what is your immediate impression of its quality? (Let’s say Ethics is 10, F&E is 9, Phil Studies is 6.5.) 2) What do you think other people’s impression is? It would also be helpful to include career status (grad student, postdoc, TT, or T) and subfield (normative/non-normative).
I recognize that asking for a rating like this is crude, but again, this matters for career outcomes, and I don’t think there’s any point denying that we have initial impressions, faulty as they may be.
I would start but don’t want to bias the results–I’ll comment my answers if this gets picked up.
What do readers think?
Leave a Reply