In our October “how can we help you?” thread, a reader writes:

What is the current opinion of Philosophy & Public Affairs? This is highly relevant to early-career folks who are deciding where to send papers, where they will be locked up for months.

My impression is that opinion is extremely split. Some people deem the new PPA as essentially unworthy of engagement beyond ridicule. But many others (especially judging by its acceptance rate remaining around 5%, according to the EIC in a recent DN thread) continue to think of it as a prestigious journal worthy of submissions. This seems to correlate strongly with background political views, with more lefty academics having the lowest regard for the new PPA.

I am trying to get a sense of whether my impression is accurate. To that end it would be helpful if folks could answer two questions. 1) When you see that an arbitrary article was published in the new PPA, what is your immediate impression of its quality? (Let’s say Ethics is 10, F&E is 9, Phil Studies is 6.5.) 2) What do you think other people’s impression is? It would also be helpful to include career status (grad student, postdoc, TT, or T) and subfield (normative/non-normative).

I recognize that asking for a rating like this is crude, but again, this matters for career outcomes, and I don’t think there’s any point denying that we have initial impressions, faulty as they may be.

I would start but don’t want to bias the results–I’ll comment my answers if this gets picked up.

What do readers think?

Posted in

35 responses to “Thoughts on “the new PPA”?”

  1. Anonymous

    PPA used to be the journal of Rawls studies. Now it’s the journal of conservative grievance studies. The arguments for conservative grievances are weaker than arguments for broadly Rawlsian positions. So the kinds of articles that are welcomed by new PPA are systematically weaker than old PPA. I give it a 6.

    Of course the new PPA will dispute that arguments for conservative grievances are weaker. But they have only to look at the weak articles they publish for evidence.

    1. Anonymous

      yes it does seem like conservatives think the new PPA is “finally a good journal,” while everyone else is either in the “it’s not a good journal anymore” or “it’s still good, but less good than Free and Equal” camp

      1. Anonymous

        “Conservatives” is not quite right. Moderates, including left-leaning moderates like myself, are generally fans of the editorial direction PPA has taken. There is a strong leftwing political bias in academic philosophy. One consequences is that weak arguments for leftwing conclusions regularly get published in top journals while strong, innovative arguments for conclusions that are rejected by leftists are rarely published in top journals and sometimes struggle to get published anywhere half decent. For people like me who want to see the best work published, including work that makes innovative arguments for conclusions that we might ultimately reject, this is a bad state of affairs. PPA is doing a good job countering this rampant leftwing bias.

      2. Anonymous

        Sure, but this means that ppl will discount the quality of papers in ppa by thinking the cause of their getting published in ppa is the conservative / libertarian / whatever nature of the take, rather than their argumentative quality. Note that this follows from your own characterization of it.

  2. Anonymous

    They recently published a paper knowing it was written by AI, and to no-one’s surprise, it was AI slop and heavily criticized for a number of undergraduate-level mistakes by actual experts in the field. That doesn’t seem very selective or prestigious to me.

    1. Anonymous

      Note that it was only known it was AI once it was already at the acceptance stage

    2. Anonymous

      Political Philosophy published a paper that, according to Pangram, is 100% AI. Actual experts in the field read the paper, concluded it was AI slop, and reported it to the publisher, who denied AI use after a brief investigation. I wonder what you think this says about the selectivity and prestige of that journal.

      1. anon

        Can you point us to more about this?

      2. Anonymous

        anon: I’m not sure how to interpret the safe and supportive mission rule here. I guess since the journal/publisher made a public statement, it seems OK to link: https://politicalphilosophyjournal.org/news/985/

  3. Anonymous

    I think it’s clearly weaker than the original PPA (although that might say something more about my priors than the actual quality of the papers), but I’m fairly confident that this judgment is shared by many political/moral philosophers.

    Note that the same is not true about Political Philosophy (the new version of JPP). I imagine most people would think that the typical PP paper is exactly the same quality as an old JPP paper. So, PPA has clearly lost some of its cachet. (For what it’s worth, I would give it a 7 or so.)

  4. Anonymous

    Political Philosophy >> PPA > Free & Equal

    1. Anonymous

      I took it that the question was not: Which journal do you think is the best? But which journal is, taken by the profession, to be the best? And if that’s the right interpretation, I don’t see how the above ranking makes sense.

  5. Anonymous

    Unrelated to the main issue, i.e., the prestige of the current PPA, but may be useful for early-career folks who are worried that their drafts may be locked up for months: I have submitted only once to PPA after Brennan and gang took over the leadership (the paper was rejected). Very quick turnaround. Courteous notes from Brennan. Experience was better than 90% of the journals that I have engaged with. So if you are not as worried about its conservative bias or image, you definitely should give it a try.

    1. Maybe I am a weird outlier here but I find it hard to say anything general about a paper’s quality just knowing the journal it was published in. A lot of Ethics papers don’t strike me as particularly great, although (perhaps coincidentally) all the stuff I read in Phil Studies tends to be pretty great (but I am much more selective about what I read from Phil Studies). I haven’t read a ton of stuff in the new PPA but what I have read has, overall, not been as good as the stuff in say) Free & Equal (which has mostly been great, so I guess maybe I can say some stuff in general about some journals) or, really, any of the other journals that I read stuff in (and I read stuff in a lot of journals!).
    2. My sense of what other people think is the same as your (OP’s) sense with the added point that some people dislike the journal not because of its standards but because they see it as a scab project undermining the power of editorial boards versus big publishers, and so that makes them think less of people who publish in the journal without having any particular views on the quality of the paper.
  6. Anonymous

    I think the important point here is that there’s enormous variance with regards to PPA. You get some people who have barely heard that anything changed at PPA (met someone like that a few months ago). And you get some who think that Brennan et al. are traitors to the cause and submitting there is like crossing the picket line. That, to me, seems like a good reason for early career folk not to submit there until things have cooled down more. On the job market, you cannot predict who’s going to be on the committee and what they will think of PPA.

    As for the impression, I’d say it’s on the same level as upper-middle journals like PPE, JESP, Economics & Philosophy etc. Something like a 7.

  7. Anonymous

    If Ethics is a 10 and Phil Studies is a 6.5, I wouldn’t be giving F&E a 9 in the first place. I’d put F&E at 8 – 8.5ish, and the new PPA at 7.5.

  8. Hmm

    Confused by Ethics being a 10, Phil Studies a 6.5, and other ethics journals between them. If I get a paper rejected from Ethics I’m then sending it to top 5 generalist journals, then 5-10 generalist, then other ethics journals (F&E, PP, JESP, newPPA) later. So all of those would have to be lower than a 6.5 on this scale. Really for moral philosophy papers I’d say 10: Ethics+top 5 generalist, 8: 5-10 generalist, 7 or thereabouts: other specialist. But if others disagree I should change my strategy 😉

  9. Read it

    Pretty mid. It leans towards repeating things accepted without argument by libertarians with a twinge of finding joy in trolls. Basically conservative light, though they publish many non-conservatives of course. I wish rather than having undertaken this path they had created a distinct journal and taken the opportunity to be clear on what their goals were. But here we are. I guess it would be fine for an early career person at a place where you just need to get stuff out and have it be seen as passable.

  10. Political Philosopher

    I second the anonymous poster that it’s on the same level as upper-mid tier journals like PPE, JESP, and E&P. I’d add JMP here too.

    While it’s true that the new PPA publishes a lot of articles with a libertarian bent, a lot of these articles could’ve been (and historically have been) published in journals like the ones mentioned above. And the new PPA has also published articles with lefty themes. See this edition for some examples: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/toc/10884963/2025/53/3

  11. Anonymous

    The comments here reveal what you should already know as a pro philosopher reading this: there is a contingent in the profession (here likely skewing to the young) who really don’t like anything that can be associated with the right. Notice that many of these comments run together libertarianism and conservatism, which are not the same thing (duh). Indeed, none of the editors of PPA are conservatives. The journal recently published a paper on conservative affirmative action, which has likely caused some of the backlash you’re seeing above.

    In general, the new PPA seems more open to publishing views the editors disagree with than did the old PPA. This means it will necessarily draw the ire of a certain crowd. Many of the negative reactions here are aimed at the journal and its editors, not the work published there. The new PPA is willing to publish non-lefty work, and so it must be discredited. There will, on the other hand, be people who see that a paper was published in PPA and think “this paper is less likely to have been waived through for having the correct conclusion.” Those thinking this way, who are not necessarily on the right, will think placement in PPA is thus a better signal than F&E (still the journal of Rawlsian studies, it would seem) or PP.

    What does that mean for young philosophers considering where to submit work? The frustrating answer is that we’re likely in a period where there is no real consensus about which journal is best. Yes, some journal would win in a Condorcet ranking, but that would paper over deeper disagreement.

    In light of this disagreement, people judging CVs and paper placement should also relax about the ranking. If authors aren’t sure which of these 3 journals is perceived as best, it doesn’t make much sense to discriminate strongly on the basis of placement. Some people are likely sending their best work to PPA first, some to PP, still others to F&E.

  12. Anonymous

    I’m a postdoc. I won’t ever submit to PPA, and many of my colleagues have similar policies. Because many people don’t submit to PPA, the journal is selecting from a smaller pool of papers, and publications in the journal are less prestigious for that reason.

    I attach no prestige to PPA. I think its editors should not have swooped in to save Wiley or caved in to the kinds of demands that motivated the earlier editors to leave. A few of the papers that were revised by the old editorial team were ready to go when they left, and PPA published some good stuff immediately following their departure. But the quality has dropped, and as others have said, PPA recently published AI slop. It is hard for me to take PPA seriously.

    Speaking purely prudentially, publishing in PPA seems risky, because many people in the profession hold it in extremely low regard and think it shouldn’t exist. There are tons of great ethics and generalist venues, like enough to submit to at least a dozen journals, one after the other. This is more than enough for a quality paper to find a home. There is no need to risk it with PPA.

    I regard a publication in the zombie PPA as well below any mid-level generalist journal (e.g. Phil Studies, Australasian, Phil Imprint) and also below generalist journals that are one wrung down (e.g. Synthese). In ethics and political philosophy, I think of Ethics as #1, followed by F&E. Next are several journals, e.g. Political Philosophy, Journal of Moral Philosophy, Oxford Studies in Normative Ethics/Metaethics, and so on. I would rather publish in a top-5 generalist journal than Ethics, I would rather publish in Ethics or F&E than Phil Studies, and I would rather publish in Phil Studies than (say) Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, though these are all great journals and I would happily publish in any of them.

    1. Anonymous

      Judging by PPA’s still very low acceptance rate relative to other ethics journals, the remark about the size of the submission pool seems off-target. Of course, we can ask about the makeup of those submissions, but it’s hard to imagine that removing the submissions of people who are anti PPA 2.0 would do much to damage the pool, except maybe the footnotes to Rawls.

    2. Anonymous

      Overkill and misleading. They didn’t cave in to the demands. They negotiated conditions which the previous editors failed to secure.

      Separate thought: One indicator of a good journal is that good philosophers publish in it. Lots of good philosophers continue to publish in PPA.

      1. Anonymous

        Hasn’t PPA changed typesetting? My understanding was that with the old journal, Wiley was pushing to remove PPA’s classic look to make it look like all of their other journals. This is a very visible change that the new leadership agreed to. Of course there were much more substantive and troubling demands from Wiley as well, so I think it’s fair to push back on that, and I take your point.

        Even if some big names submit to PPA, it must count for something that there is a big part of the profession that doesn’t submit there on principle, including the whole editorial team of F&E and many of their colleagues, as well as third parties who think that PPA never should have been revived.

        I don’t work on Rawls, and neither do my peers who don’t submit to PPA.

  13. Anonymous

    It is difficult to compare specialist and generalist journals, but I personally think that the rankings have changed significantly since the last poll, and not only because of the PPA episode.

    My ranking is roughly:

    Ethics > F&E, PP > PPE, JESP > PPA, JMP, Oxford Studies, Utilitas > Others

  14. Anonymous

    I find it very hard to put numbered rankings to these journals, but I will say this: some set of people (very plausibly more than half, but at least as plausibly much less) will think that PPA remains where it was; some set of people (I think here much more plausibly more than half) have a strongly negative view of it now. My anecdotal experience as an advanced Associate Professor in social/political philosophy at an R1 is that normative folks are much more likely to know about the change and view it negatively. Folks outside of normative philosophy are less likely to know about the change, and to still see a pub there as a signal of good work. But if you’re on the job market in ethics/social/political, you probably either have mostly normative folks on the search committee, or you have folks who will see PPA as very prestigious and so a flight risk indicator. Either way not good for your chances. Even without any substantive considerations about the bent of the new journal or the new team taking over after the previous board left, I think that the prudential considerations are strong enough that I wouldn’t ever submit there as a junior person.

  15. anon

    Just one perspective here. I think that in some important respects the new PPA has a more interesting variety of topics than the old PPA. But the new-era articles I’ve read–only a few so far–are not nearly as good in terms of both scholarship and argumentation. This makes it tumble down the rankings in my head. There’s no substitute for an article being very well executed, regardless of topic.

    (Despite concerns about ranking, I did submit a piece there since the change of guard. I got really shoddy refereeing, like at a level of incompetence in understanding arguments. This can and does happen at any journal, of course, but the experience made me wonder if new practices between referee and editor are contributing to quality slippage. I think it will be awhile before I submit there again.)

  16. Anonymous

    I would rate it not quite as much a non-pub as e.g. Philosophia or Journal of Controversial Ideas, I’m not sure that like those I’d hold it against e.g. a job market candidate on the margin, but I would put it sufficiently far down my rankings for political philosophy that I wouldn’t attach much more significance to it than a publication in e.g. Journal of Value Inquiry or Analyse & Kritik. It is very plain to see that it has fallen far in terms of editorial board, reputation, selectivity, and I expect its reputation to continue to fall far in the coming years as people’s awareness of its current standards catches up with the historical pedigree.

    1. Anonymous

      Philosophia is a non-pub!? I wasn’t aware of this.

    2. Anonymous

      The selectivity is around 5% as of a month ago.

      1. Another anonymous

        The question is not just how many things they reject, but what they select.

  17. Anonymous

    One thing that hasn’t been commented on is the way that the old PPA handled peer review. All of its submissions were reviewed in-house by a very impressive group of established philosophers (indeed, stars in the field). This meant that anything that got published there got their imprimatur. Of course, that opens up all sorts of problems re: bias and orthodoxy, but it also signaled something important about the quality of each paper. Since that’s no longer the case at the new PPA, that might partly explain why philosophers rate it less highly.

  18. sahpa

    > leftyish philosophers refuse to publish in the new PPA
    > PPA receives only submissions from non-leftyish philosophers
    > PPA publishes only papers from non-leftyish philosophers
    > this fact is treated as confirmation of rightward bias and justification for refusing to publish in the new PPA
    > rinse and repeat

    You don’t even have to posit bias at the editorial or reviewer level.

    1. Anonymous

      Bingo

  19. Anonymous

    From the perspective of a junior person trying to publish, I think it’s a net positive to have another journal in political philosophy to send stuff to. I also think pluralism in terms of ideological bent, topics, etc. across journals is generally a good thing that is likely to improve the quality of work in the field as a whole.

    I also don’t really understand the sentiment that the new PPA is a scab. To be clear, I support Free & Equal and I’m glad they left Wiley to start a new journal that is independent of profit-seeking publishing companies, and I am happy to see this becoming something of a trend. Still, scab accusations typically mean that the scab undermines the strikers (in this case, Free & Equal). But (a) I can’t see how the existence of the new PPA undermines Free & Equal in any way, and (b) it’s almost laughable to see leftists being so eager to protect the standing of Free & Equal, which is, you know, representing the *elite* of the field.

Leave a Reply