In our October “how can we help you?” thread, a reader writes:

I almost always get overwhelmed by grading at this time of every semester. I teach around 3 courses per semester, and we only have an undergraduate program without TAs. We are a R2 public institution, and the quality of students’ work is poor. Grading is not fun.

I have two questions. First, I really enjoy teaching, but I hate grading (though I understand that it is an integral part of teaching). I wonder outside of the classroom, roughly how do you divide your time between course preparation and grading? What is the approximate ratio of time spent on each? (I understand that there are many factors, such as how many times you have taught a course before, the course-levels, etc. Let us just think generally.)

Second, do you have any practical tips or even tricks to handle boring grading?

I’m curious too! How much grading does everyone do, and do you have any helpful tips for making it more tolerable?

Posted in

19 responses to “Tips for making grading more tolerable?”

  1. Anonymous

    two things helped me. first, it helped to move to exams rather than papers. my exams still include open-ended questions but I find that they’re way easier to grade than papers. second, I started using a clustering approach where I read through all the responses and just try to sort them into three or four different piles based on how similar they are to one another (no commenting at this initial stage). then after I have my piles, I’ll decide that the one pile are the As, the other pile are the Bs and so on (here is where I go back and tack on some comments). can’t explain why this has sped things up but it really has cut down my grading time and helped me keep my sanity!

  2. Anonymous

    I absolutely hate grading as well!

  3. Anonymous

    I absolutely hate grading as well and I don’t spend that much time on it anymore.

    A few things that have helped me make it tolerable:

    First, I never give detailed line feedback to any papers. I only give overall comments.

    Second, I don’t have a lot of writing/paper assignments in my class. I do more creative projects, discussion posts, self-graded quizzes, and lots of participation points for showing up.

    Third, much of my grading is basically pass/fail, so I just have to check off whether they did an assignment and met the requirements instead of having to do a fine-grain judgment.

    1. Anonymous

      If you never give detailed comments, how do students improve? And if you don’t do many papers/written assignments, how do students learn to think deeply and over an extended period of time rather than give vibe-based responses in the moment?

      1. Anonymous

        Would love to know the teaching load of someone who thinks this way and/or if they have any ambition to write. I teach a 4/4 and do not give line by line comments unless it is in Senior Seminar or helping with grad school writing samples.

      2. Anonymous

        I think there’s a presupposition here that students read the detailed comments! I tell students to come to office hours for more detailed comments.

      3. Peter Finocchiaro

        There is some research that indicates students, even those who read detailed comments, are only able to internalize a relatively limited amount of feedback. So more detailed comments can have the opposite of the intended effect: students get overwhelmed and fail to engage with any of it when they would have been able to engage with a much more limited amount of feedback on the paper overall.

        I still give detailed comments to my students. But I am not always optimistic that they read them or benefit from them.

  4. Anonymous

    I always spoil myself. I go to a nice coffee shop, order whatever I want, eat lunch out. Doesn’t make it fun, but it gives me something that day to look forward to.

  5. Plato

    Move some of your work into the classroom. I do a paper workshop where students share abstracts each other and give feedback, and I use this time to go around the classroom and give feedback on students’ proposals and/or rough drafts. This way, when I grade the full paper I’ve already helped move them in better directions and so reading their papers is more enjoyable. But grading will never be as fun as teaching. That’s just how it is.

  6. Anonymous

    This really depends on how many students you have in those classes, but with a 4/4 and about 20-25 students in each, I conduct a lot of oral exams and/or grade written work via a conference in which I deliver feedback and I ask them to suggest a grade based on that (and a set of grading standards I’ve already shared with them). It’s a lot of work and can get a bit tedious/ tiring, but more often, it’s a genuinely educational experience and it more or less removes the possibility of procrastination. I combine that with some writing graded by completion, (usually reflective-type writing or impressions of the reading) plus some objective answer quizzes (to encourage basic knowledge of the readings, etc.). There’s no getting around a certain level of awfulness, but these things have made it a lot better for me.

    I’m teaching all lower-level gen ed classes, few to no philosophy majors.

  7. Anonymous

    I tell myself that if I mark as quickly as I can, I can go back to doing my own research.

  8. Anonymous

    Motivationally, here is something that helps me. Maybe it will help you. Do a rough calculation of what percentage of your overall yearly work a given set of grading is (or for adjuncts, what percentage of the work for that specific course). Do the math to think about how much you are being paid to grade that set of papers/tests/etc. It will often come out to a seemingly absurd amount. “Wait, I am being paid $600 to grade these tests? Damn, that’s a good deal!”

    1. Anonymous

      I like this approach. The only trouble is that there is no fixed amount of grading– since I determine how much I assign. This causes trouble for how to calculate the payment. But in general it does work for me to think about teaching favorably: teaching is largely the only thing that I am paid to do that I probably wouldn’t be doing otherwise. Then divide salary, and each class makes 2k$! That motivates the prep for each class a lot.

      *Numbers are for illustration purposes and not factually correct.

  9. Bill

    Grading is the worst part of the job, hands down.

    I stagger my classes’ various due dates, so I don’t get all the essays in the same week.

    For things like discussion boards or weekly reading response assignments, I do spot checks but only grade for completion and give very little/no feedback.

    Our classes are all designated “writing intensive” so I feel a responsibility to give some feedback to help students improve their essays. I frontload that: the first essay gets more feedback than the final one, or if it is a draft-and-revised-version assignment, the draft gets comments and the revised version doesn’t (except for an occasional petulant “I see you didn’t follow the advice I gave you on your draft”).

    I have a bank of comments in a Word doc so I can copy-and-paste when I am grading in Canvas, for feedback on common issues. I built the bank by making regular comments on essays, and copying those into the bank. Then, the next time, I add to or edit the bank as needed, and personalize the feedback as seems useful.

    I try to keep in mind that the writers of the essays that need the most help are the ones who can processes the least feedback in one bite. I try to identify something easy to fix, something that would make a big difference, or similar, then refrain from making every possible comment. For cases with bad mechanics, I make a suggestion to visit the Writing Center “to take your writing to the next level” (which is vague enough to seem aspirational instead of aspersional, if that is a word). VERY few students ever come looking for more feedback (I suspect many don’t read/process what I do give them).

    My best trick is giving myself a time limit to grade each essay. Seven to twelve minutes seems to be the sweet spot for me, depending on the level of the class and the length of the essay. After that, the problem of diminishing returns kicks in–the value students get from additional feedback is much less than the the pain/time I would spend giving it. Sometimes I actually use a timer on my phone to force myself to keep going, and to stick to the time limit.

    Something I learned from the time management tool called the Pomodoro Technique is to take five minute breaks every 30 minutes or so. That makes it possible to sustain attention for several hours.

    I spend something like four to six work days per semester (mostly broken into smaller chunks) grading four undergrad classes for a typical total of 100-120 students. Given that there are 75 week days in a 15-week semester, that isn’t too bad.

  10. It’s very hard to say anything general, but I’d say with a new course, the divide is about 30% course prep and 70% grading (in terms of time spent), and with a course I’ve taught before and to which I am making no modifications, the divide is about 5-10% course prep and 90-95% grading.

  11. Anonymous

    For grading intensive classes (eg. 100+ exams to grade) I split it into 10 a day. I do my 10 first thing in the morning and then move on with my day/emails/my own research/laundry. That way I don’t feel like I’m “wasting” entire days grading. Ideally, I don’t start my work day until noon. So I have until noon every morning for my other tasks (laundry, cleaningC shopping, emails, grading etc.) then around noon I get to my tasks until it is dinner time.

    Paper copies of exams / essays are also way easier to grade I’ve found (easier on the eyes, can find a comfy spot ect.) and in my in-person classes I always try to go low-tech so most assignments are written/in-person rather than online.

    Unlike the above commenter, I also prefer when I make my deadlines for multiple classes all on the same day. That way I can plan to be swamped the following 1-2 weeks with grading and not have grading take up the entire semester. I also limit my assignments to 3-4 big assignments in a course, I find marking little assignments constantly so draining and exhausting (and as a student I HATED constant little assignments to keep track of).

    For context, as an instructor now for like 1-3 courses a semester my grading is nothing compared to when I would work 5+ TA positions a semester (I worked for my uni plus another uni). Being a TA was way worse because you have no control over the assignments/timing/expectations and with every proff you have to keep track of what they want. Yes I still suffer as I grade LOL but now its just me torturing myself. The worst part now, imo, is the constant student complaining. I hate answering the AI emails student send trying to negotiate their grade, with some students it don’t matter what you tell them or how much feedback you give, it will always be “still unclear why they got this grade” and they will just immediately AI a response back to you.

  12. Anonymous

    Two suggestions:

    1. (This one is thanks to Dien Ho, who gave me this advice like 10 years ago and almost certainly doesn’t remember it, but I remember *him* gratefully every time I grade essays) Grade only in coffee shops. New coffee shop every 5 essays. New delicious baked good every new coffee shop. (Obviously money/time/number of students matters here, but it turns out I am highly treat motivated.)
    2. Try to make the assignments ones you care about more, and where you get more variety in responses. In my intro feminist philosophy class, I ask the students to write a letter to their younger self about something from the class they wish they’d known earlier in their life. They have to explain the idea/concept/argument in a way that a smart 16 year old could understand, explain why it’s something that matters (to them or more generally), and consider and respond to the places their younger self might be skeptical. It’s basically an argumentative essay, but they seem to take the assignment really seriously, and I find them really compelling to read – especially the part about why they think the ideas matter.
  13. Anonymous

    I’ve always found it a bit confusing how people who hate grading can enjoy teaching, at least where the hatred of grading is due to the poor quality of the student work. Does it not diminish your sense of the meaningfulness of teaching that the students seem to internalize little to nothing from what you teach? Do you just like hearing yourself talk?

    1. Anonymous

      OP here. I can only speak for myself. I’ve taught full-time for almost a decade now at my R2 public school. I enjoy teaching but hate grading. I do not think of teaching as hearing myself talk. I guess there are several considerations here.

      First, the written work is only part of the learning process. I still enjoy the in-class discussions and interactions with students. But at least to me, there is a big gap between the quality of the in-class discussion and the written work.

      Second, it is sad to admit that for most classes I taught (mostly lower level gen ed ones), the majority of the students did “internalize little to nothing” from what I taught. For example, no matter what method I tried, most of them just did not read anything before class. They just did not care. However, I really enjoyed my time interacting with around 10-20% of the students, who established serious interests in philosophy. I am happy with that and cannot ask for more.

Leave a Reply