In our October “how can we help you?” thread, a reader writes:

How good are journals at gatekeeping AI? I’m slightly a bit worried, mainly because I have stakes in it, that articles published pre-2022 will count significantly more than those published post-arrival.

Do any readers have helpful insights to share?

Posted in , ,

5 responses to “How good are journals at gatekeeping AI?”

  1. Anonymous

    What does this question mean? Like, if they “count less” after 22, they “count less” for everybody, and since “counting” is only relative to others, things will stay the same..

    1. Anonymous

      maybe they didn’t publish as much early in their career or expect to compete for jobs with people who have been in the profession longer than they have

      1. Anonymous

        i can understand the first option, but the second option would still mean that they’re evaluated against their peers, who also submit after 22…

  2. sahpa

    I suppose my only insight is from the point of view of practical reason: I don’t see how that worry — if it proved true — should affect your decision-making in the least. What would you even do with that information? You can’t go back in time and improve your pre-2022 publication record.

    1. Anonymous

      Well maybe op is considering whether it makes sense to leave academia — just an illustration that the answer to op’s question is relevant to decision making.

Leave a Reply