Guest post by Eric Steinhart, Professor of Philosophy at William Paterson University
I work at a teaching university. It’s a mid-sized state university. Many, many jobs are at schools like mine. And if you want to join our faculty, if you’re applying for a job, I want to know about your teaching. If you can teach, you’ll do very well at a university like mine. You’ll have plenty of time for your research and your life. If you can’t teach, you won’t do well at universities like mine; in fact, if you can’t teach, you’ll fail very, very quickly. Sadly, I’ve seen this failure happen more than once.
So we care about your teaching. It’s pretty much all we care about. If you can’t demonstrate your teaching skill in your application, we’re going to move on very quickly to look at the next application. For evidence, we want to see your teaching statement, and we want to see syllabi. Unfortunately, most teaching statements don’t tell us anything about your teaching. So let me ask you some specific questions. By answering them, you can fill out a teaching statement. And, if we do interview you, we’re going to ask most of these questions anyway. So it’s good to be prepared.
- What do you actually do in the classroom? Do you just stand there and lecture? Do you lecture with power point? Our students don’t respond very well to those styles. They’ll be checking their phones or not showing up. What do you do besides lecture? Sure, group-work is fine, but what specifically do you mean? Do you use games? Role playing games to teach ethical theories? Debates? Do you use worksheets? Tell me exactly about what you do in the classroom.
- Do you just do traditional in-person teaching? Have you done online teaching? Hybrid? Tell me all about your online teaching. If not, do you want to?
- What do you use for texts? Do you use big expensive anthologies? Do you use lots of books or just a few? Have you thought about the impact of textbook costs on your students? Our students are on very, very tight budgets. Do you use open access materials (e.g. freely available PDFs)? What are your thoughts about the ability of our students to read the material? They’re just out of high school; they come from varying socio-economic contexts; they are almost all first-generation students. Can they read what you’re assigning? How many pages per week do you expect them to read? Nobody reads anymore anyway. How will you deal with that? And how inclusive and diverse are your materials?
- Do you use any materials besides texts? Do you have a list of curated YouTube videos and Podcasts? Do you put links to these on the course software (e.g. Blackboard, Canvas, or other learning management system)? Do you use software like the game of life? Maybe have them watch episodes of Black Mirror or Rick & Morty? Tell me about all the things you use besides texts.
- What technologies do you use? Just the blackboard? Power point? Videos? Maybe you use a box with a rock in it to illustrate Berkeley’s esse est percipi. Do you cover yourself with a blanket to illustrate the veil of ignorance? How about having them do experiments? Do you use learning management systems like Blackboard or Canvas? Do you use electronic discussion boards? Tell me about all the technologies you use.
- How about student technologies? How do you handle student uses of devices in class? Do you try to ban them? How will you enforce that? Many students have the reading materials on their laptops or use their devices to take notes. Do you encourage them to look things up on Google or other search engines? How about giving them in-class assignments to find answers on the net?
- What is the structure of a typical class? Is it just you standing there talking? Here’s an alternative: start each class by presenting a question; give students ten minutes to write out an answer; then have every student read or speak based on their response. Or have students do individual presentations. Or have them regularly complete worksheets in groups. Or flip the classroom. Do you let students vote on possible activities? Tell me every single thing you do besides just stand there and lecture.
- What sorts of assignments do you give? Just one long term paper at the end? If that’s your answer, then you’re not going to do well here. How about giving them a short (e.g. 1pg ss) paper every week? Make them find a relevant article on the web every week and write a ½ pg summary of it. Use graded worksheets. Give objective format tests. Do you let students work on the tests together? Do you do take home tests? Tell me every single thing you do besides a term paper.
- How many assignments do you give? Just one at the end of the term. Just a few? One or more every week? How often do student grades get updated? Just end of term? Every month? Every week? How often do you post their grades? If you post to an electronic system, like Blackboard or Canvas, that’s great. If not, how do you inform them? How do you check for plagiarism? Tell me everything about the kinds of assignments you give.
- How are assignments evaluated? Do you grade them as you see fit? How will you deal with their complaints? If you’re going to mark up their papers with a red pen, have you informed them in advance what you’re looking for? Do you use explicit rubrics which you give to the students before the assignment? Do you give objective format tests? Do you have students grade each others’ work? You might have them give presentations and have the students evaluate the presentations. Tell me everything about your grading policies and practices.
- How often do you communicate with the class? Just in class? Do you ever send them email? How often? Every week? Tell me about the logistics. And how often do you assess your class? If things aren’t going well, how will you change that? What about attendance? Do you take it every class? How about office hours? Do you require students to visit your hours? Tell me all the particular details of your communication and logistics. Show me you can manage the practical details of the classroom.
- How do you handle students who struggle because they’re working part-time or full-time, or who struggle because of their family situations? Do you allow them to do make-up work when they missed class? Do you allow them to do a certain number of online assignments (e.g. worksheets) to make up some missed classes? Do you allow late work? What do you do to deal with the very messy lives of your students. Tell me.
Leave a Reply