In our thread the other day discussing whether it is okay to submit a radically different version of a paper to a journal that already rejected it, several commenters suggested writing a 'cover letter' to the editor explaining the situation. One reader wrote, 'this might be a good occasion to use the barely-used "cover letter" feature for submissions', which manuscript central submission portals normally have. This got me thinking: in what other types of cases might it be a good idea to submit with a cover letter?
Earlier this week, I noted that I have a longish reply paper, and that the problem I'm facing is that most journals don't accept replies to papers in other journals. Might this be a good case to submit with a cover letter–explaining for example that while the paper replies to a particular argument by a single author, the paper nevertheless has broader implications that warrants considering it as a standalone paper?
I vaguely recall that, back in the day, before online manuscript portals were used, cover letters for journal submissions were basically the norm. For example, Thom Brooks' Publishing Advice for Graduate Students (2008) states, "When sending off your submission, always include a cover letter…" (p. 18). I also vaguely remember being instructed by mentors that cover letters should provide a very brief explanation what the paper is about and why it is a good fit for the journal.
So, anyway, I'm wondering: when is it a good idea to include a cover letter with a submission? Do journal editors, in particular, think the practice ever helps authors. If so, in which kinds of cases?
Leave a Reply