In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

I've heard different things about moving jobs before/after tenure. Is it easier after or before, or in what circumstances? I see sometimes senior people moving around a bunch, and the process seems much more informal for those sorts of moves. I'm looking to find a more research-supportive job and wondering what the likelihood of this is, and how to increase the odds. Is it done via networking, making it known to various people that I'm "available", so to speak, rather than just applying to positions posted on philjobs (which tend to be junior)?

Excellent questions. Another reader submitted the following comment:

I think it is much easier to move before tenure. I did move from a 4 year state college to a research university – but after 15 years! I was more or less resigned to staying where I was – a place that offered little support for research. My sense, based on my experience, is that you have to publish a hell of a lot, in good places, and work that gets attention in order to move post tenure from a teaching institution to a research institution. I know at least one person who has an endowed chair at an elite university whose work has less than 60 % of the number of citations that my work has. But he got there early in his career. And I did not. Since the move, I have published much more, and have been invited to numerous conference, etc.

This is my sense too. As for how to best increase the odds of moving to more research-supportive jobs (whether by networking or just applying to positions), I've heard before from well-placed sources that the former works better–which coheres with broader research that the vast majority of jobs are obtained through networking. But this is just what I've heard.

Do any other readers have any helpful tips or insights? It would be great to hear from people who have moved before or after tenure, as well as from people on the hiring side of things.

Posted in

2 responses to “Moving to a research-supportive job before or after tenure? How?”

  1. Tenured now

    I moved from an R2 land grant university and undergrad only department to an R1 with a Phd program, and did it right before getting tenure. As you say, the vast majority of jobs are junior, and many, many places will not consider a tenured person for a junior job. Occasionally more senior jobs will come up, but I am currently on a search committee for a senior job, and the CVs of the people applying are terrifying – there is absolutely no way I would have gotten my job if I were applying alongside these people. (And anecdotally, basically everyone I know who has moved post tenure has done it as part of a targeted hire – so, yes, through networking.) So yes, if you are pre-tenure and wanting to move, apply NOW.

  2. cecil burrow

    I can see how for the very short papers considered in Analysis summaries might not be needed. But in journals that accept longer papers, I suspect things might be different. It is useful for an editor to get a sense of what I (the referee) think the paper is up to, to make sense of why I might make certain criticisms, as the criticisms of the paper typically depend on what the goal of the paper is taken to be. (I think it’s also useful for the author to see what the referee took the paper to be about, in case there are misconceptions that could be addressed in a future version.) I’d be interested to hear from editors of other journals as to whether they agree with this.

Leave a Reply