By Paul De Font Reaulx (PhD Student, University of Michigan)
In my experience, being an aspiring academic involves a lot of autonomous work on long-term projects with relatively little feedback that makes clear when you have made progress. This can make it hard to have a sense of what you’re concretely getting for each hour devoted. For example, I expect few of us could say with any confidence what the concrete result would be of working one more hour per day for a month.
I think this vague intuitive grasp of what we can produce with our time can lead to a few negative outcomes. For example, some of us might be familiar with the experience of devoting a lot of time to a project because it is important, only to procrastinate until an impending deadline makes the value of our time concrete. This plausibly causes stress and guilt, and in the worst case burnout. Most obviously, however, it robs us of time we could be spending on other things.
In an attempt to make the value of my own time more concrete, I tried to figure out what I should expect to get done if I worked a few hours per day for some period of time. I found the results valuable and wrote up this post to share them in case anyone else would benefit as well. The main takeaway is that the classic advice of writing every day seems, unsurprisingly, to be good advice.
In what follows, I estimate the total hours gained from a period of consistent work and compare this to estimates of the total hours required to complete a range of projects. I then check how these results are affected by variations, such as working more or taking a break. Finally, I compare the numbers to other leisure activities.
NB: I have written this from the perspective of, and primarily for, young scholars and graduate students, but I would be happy if any of it turns out to be useful to more senior people as well.
Set-up
Let’s start by calculating the total work hours we would get from a period of consistent effective work. By effective I mean mostly undivided attention (e.g. the level of concentration one might have playing a slow strategy game), meaning that working while checking social media regularly plausibly disqualifies it for most people. For those thinking in terms of pomodoros, I’m taking 1 hour to be 2 pomodoros.
I will use 16 weeks as the default period of comparison. I believe this is a standard length of a university term which makes it a natural way to chunk periods for me, and I imagine most readers. I also think it is a nice period to compare many longer projects to. Finally, assuming 4 weeks of vacation, it’s 1/3 of the work year, which makes it easy to scale.
How many hours of work per day should we be considering? It is tempting to focus on the 8h/per day of the standard workday. However, few people can work efficiently for 8h or do 16 pomodoros per day, at least consistently for extended periods. I for example have only successfully done so a handful of times during very busy periods. In further support, this survey suggests that the average office worker in the UK works efficiently 2h and 53min per working day on average. (Admittedly, this survey doesn't exactly look peer-reviewed, and should probably be taken with a pinch of salt).
Instead, my default assumption will be that we are working 4h/day, 5 days a week. This is a number that I think requires effort to meet, but that many people can do when they don’t have substantial other duties. For example, one might have a 2h working block in the morning, and one 2h block in the afternoon or evening. However, this might be difficult for people with other obligations—including, I imagine, most employed professors—so I will also compare the result of working 2h/day, and 1h/day (e.g. for dedicated writing). Later, I consider how common variations to these assumptions affect the total output.
Hours generated from consistent work
How many total hours of work do we get from working 4h/day, 5 days a week for 16 weeks? The answer is 320 hours. It is difficult to have a sense how much this is, so let us compare it to estimations of the total hours required to complete some typical projects:
This is a sample of projects that were somewhat easy for me to get data on. The hours of the graduate essay and the seminar are my own estimations, based on the time it took me to write a mediocre paper for a seminar and all hours devoted to another seminar that I found relatively demanding. The top publication (published in top-5 philosophy journal) number is from a friend who tracks all of their worked hours and was kind enough to share this with me. I expect that this number can vary quite a lot between people and that for some it might be significantly lower. In this case, the number does not include background reading, but does include all subsequent work. I also included the time I put towards my BPhil thesis at Oxford. All of these should be taken with a pinch of salt and can obviously be replaced with your own estimates, but I hope they provide some sense of proportion.
My primary takeaway from this is that consistent work is more valuable than I would have intuitively expected. For example, it is noteworthy to me that a skilled person working 2h/day and taking weekends off—which to me seems lower than the time most academics devote to their work—should expect to produce around 2 very good publications a year.
This suggests to me that it is a much more common way to underperform to devote a lot of time to a project and use it ineffectively than it is to devote too little time to it. As a supporting case study, the friend whose data I received above worked on average almost exactly 2h/day on the days they worked, and worked around 60-80% of the days of the year, depending on the year. However, with this work, they managed to be one of the most productive young scholars that I personally know. In other words, it seems one can meet a pretty high bar by consistently working few hours and not even permit oneself to work more.
Variations
What happens if you vary the assumptions above? For example, how much is gained from working more? And how much does one lose from taking a vacation? Here are some examples of variations and interventions next to the 4h/day, 5 days a week, 16-week duration baseline.
These examples are what I imagine to be pretty typical and realistic scenarios that people might consider. For the “2h more every 2 days” I’m imagining working 6h/day 2 or 3 days a week, and analogously for working 2h less every 2 days. I imagine that a 5-day conference takes 5 work days (it might be less if it’s on a day you wouldn’t have worked, but my experience is that neglected obligations usually take a day to catch up on anyway), and a 2 week vacation takes 10 work days. I assume that burnout means no productive work during that period. Realistically, burnout can plausibly last much longer than a term, meaning that the cost would be much greater than indicated here.
What is noteworthy to me about this is the relatively low marginal value of working more, within realistic bounds. For example, I have noticed that adding 2h extra work per day, even if it’s only every other day, is rather difficult for me. In particular, the risk of my schedule breaking and me procrastinating because I feel less urgency both go up significantly, which I expect outweighs the 25% increase of hours in the scenario where all goes well.
Another observation is the effect of burnout. Even if the risk is low, the disproportionate effect on productivity is so significant that it seems prudent to be very careful to avoid that outcome, even if that means taking an extra 2-week vacation (i.e. lose 40 work hours/a mediocre term paper).
One important consideration that this representation of the value of time abstracts away from is the marginal value of the work produced. For example, for a junior academic, I assume that the first great paper they produce is likely more important for them than the second, and so on. More generally, I would imagine that for most people getting some work done is much more valuable than doubling that work. This further reinforces the case for working a lower number of hours if that means reducing the risk of doing much less due to severe procrastination or burnout.
Leisure
One of the benefits of working fewer hours is having more time to spend on other activities we enjoy. Mostly for fun, I decided to do some estimations of common leisure activities too (because, yes, planned fun is the best fun.) Here are some examples I found, again compared to the 4h/day, 5 days a week, 16 week reference:
I got most of these estimations from googling around. Importantly, the gym number does not include preparation, transport, and shower. If those are included, I think that number could easily double. Like with the project examples, this list could be expanded to be more representative and helpful.
I don’t have much to comment on this beyond the obvious that most of us were aware of, namely that social media takes time. It does also frighten me a bit how many books young me could have read instead of levelling his undead warlock.
Final notes
My intention with this post was to provide some information and simple analysis that anyone could produce but I suspect few will. A reader will have to decide what to take away from it if anything.
Let me note some final caveats. Personal preferences might substantially affect how it makes sense to work. For example, someone might prefer to work longer but more relaxed hours than the level of concentration assumed here. Or by contrast, someone might prefer binge-working many hours for shorter periods. And others might be constrained in how they approach work by attention-affecting conditions like ADD. None of what I have said here is meant to override such considerations.
Whatever your situation, I hope some of this could be of use. For me, writing it provided a nice source of procrastination.



Leave a Reply