In our most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader writes:
I have a somewhat minor question, but I think it could be useful for others. How common/useful/recommended is it to suggest specific reviewers when submitting a paper to a journal?
I've come to learn that it is quite common in other fields. Researchers tend to suggest reviewers they think will be congenial to the paper's argument. And, not always but to a greater degree than I would have expected, these reviewers are actually assigned by the editors.
I've never done that in philosophy, fearing that it would be seen poorly by the editors or that the suggested reviewers may guess that I'm the author (unlikely, given my career stage). But none of these considerations seem to weigh heavily in other fields.
Some journals have made me do this as an author. At best, I find it irksome, as journals can require you to hunt down contact information. At worst, it seems to me a way to potentially corrupt the peer-review process, in that authors are more or less self-selecting who they'd prefer to review their paper (many authors give papers at colloquia, send around papers to colleagues, etc.). So personally, I prefer not to see this done. But, in any case, it would seem strange to me to propose reviewers to journals that don't explicitly request or require it.
What do you all think? Is this a common or useful practice?
Leave a Reply