In our most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:
How do you handle editors and reviewers from cross-disciplinary journals not understanding philosophical style and research (and rejecting a paper because it's more of an "opinion piece" rather than what their discipline deems "research" or because they consider the use of first-person pronouns "informal")? This is a pattern I've noticed especially among reviewers with a computer science background, but I'm sure it's not limited to them.
I've never run into this problem, but I guess my hot-take is that I'd simply try to learn and adhere to their conventions as much as is feasible. But if reviewers at a journal aren't willing to consider philosophical arguments (deeming them "opinion pieces"), then maybe the journal just isn't a good fit for the piece.
Do other readers, perhaps ones with more experience on this, have any helpful tips to share?
Leave a Reply