In our new "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

I've reworked 2 chapters from my dissertation and sent them to journals. There's another chapter that I could possibly rework to send off to a journal. But I also want to eventually turn my dissertation into a book, and I think that if most of my dissertation already appears in print, I wouldn't be able to do that. Should I save that chapter?

This is a good question, particularly in light of yesterday's thread. I've heard that (some?/many?) book publishers may be reticent to publish dissertations, but then again, I've heard of more than a few cases of people publishing them, so I'm not sure exactly what to believe. In any case, I'm not sure what to recommend here. Maybe it depends on how long the dissertation was? If it was a short (e.g. 4 or 5 chapter) dissertation, then publishing half or more than half of it in journals could well be a problem. But, if the dissertation was longer, maybe not.

What does everyone think? It would be great to hear from those with some experience here.

Posted in

9 responses to “Saving (some) dissertation chapters for a book?”

  1. three time author

    Personally, I am not sure it is worth trying to publish your dissertation as a book. First, the publishers do not want to publish dissertations (unless you are in Germany where there is a market for it, and a requirement to do it). Second, in all likelihood, a (typical) dissertation does not warrant being published as a book. They are usually too short. And they lack the depth that comes with maturing as a scholar, which comes with publishing more. I would recommend just sending the third chapter out to a journal.

  2. Chris

    Another way to go – maybe you’ve already considered and rejected this idea – would be to go ahead an publish as much of the dissertation as you can as articles and then think of writing a book on the same topic but not using the articles as chapters. That is, revisiting the material, explaining it better, responding to objections to the articles, expanding beyond the scope of the dissertation, etc. Of course, this is more work, and would probably mean delaying publication of the book.
    How long was the dissertation? Many dissertations (esp these days) aren’t long enough for a book. So if you’re going to need to add new material anyway…

  3. Assistant prof

    As someone who wrote a book drawing heavily on my dissertation, I wouldn’t recommend it unless you’re in a very special situation (which I was).
    You can get plenty of articles out of your dissertation, and until you’ve built up an audience through articles it’s hard to get anyone to publish or read a book anyways. And in many subfields, you get more credit professionally (and towards tenure) for publishing articles.
    There are definitely situation-specific reasons for wanting to write a book that draws on your dissertation. But this is highly unusual and not fun.

  4. My impression here might be off, but I think most Tenure and Promotion committees like articles more than books (page for page, obviously). In that tenure requires establishing a research program beyond the dissertation, publishing the dissertation as a book, especially if it is mostly repeating what is already in print, will count for even less. Maybe not worth trying?

  5. Elizabeth

    I published my revised dissertation as a book with OUP. However, my dissertation was a monograph style that developed an original argument and then applied it to multiple different cases. Publishing it as individual papers would have required making the same argument multiple times in each paper in order to understand the application. So it worked much better as a book.

  6. Precariously Employed

    Just curious in response to Chris’s comment, how long are dissertations in general today? My recently defended thesis was just under 95 000 words (275ish pages) and I thought that was pretty typical (at least compared to the other dissertations that came out of my department when I was there). That seems like plenty for a book? Or am I underestimating how many words are in standard philosophy books.
    I would also like to jump in here to ask Elizabeth how she feels about that decision in retrospect? I ask because I am in a similar position (I could probably get around 4 papers from my thesis and have published one already, but there are major parts that only really work as part of the larger whole). My committee really encouraged me to try to get a book contract because they thought that it worked best as a book length project but I am also in short-term LTA hell right now, so pushing out non-thesis papers or polishing a book both seem like impossible tasks given my teaching workload. So, I’m currently very on the fence and would appreciate hearing what others have thought about their decisions in the short and long term.

  7. Elizabeth

    To Precariously Employed…
    I’m happy with my decision. I might have made a different decision had a top press not accepted it. In that case the decision would have been articles vs low press and I’d probably have gone with articles. I’m about to be tenured, so it has all worked out for thr best I think.

  8. Chris

    RE: dissertation length: many dissertations are probably more like half the length of yours – there is the “three paper” model where you might have three chapters, each about 10-12K, plus introductory and concluding chapters. Some departments say e.g., 150 – 300 pages and absolutely won’t consider anything more than 400 pages.
    Of course, at lot depends on your area and program. History of philosophy dissertations tend to be longer than logic ones, etc.
    I say all this without making claims about whether this trend is good or bad.
    You might be interested in Marcus’ old post about this on the Cocoon:
    https://philosopherscocoon.typepad.com/blog/2013/04/whats-going-on-with-dissertations.html

  9. anon

    a lot of students are writing a3-paper thesis nowadays whether their area is history of phil or not (some shorter some longish ~150 pp). they publish in good journals and land on good jobs. so it seems this trend has more advantages.

Leave a Reply