In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:
I am a masters student in philosophy and I currently have a paper under external review at one of the "top-25 general philosophy journals" listed on this webpage:
https://leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2022/07/best-general-philosophy-journals-2022.html
Of course, I am happy and excited and nervous and somewhat terrified about this at the same time! And I have a couple questions about this kind of experience:
1. Since I'm applying to PhD programs in the upcoming cycle, I wonder if it would be appropriate for me to list the paper in the "under review" section of my c.v.? (I've seen many early career philosophers do that, so I was curious.)
2. If the answer to the previous question is affirmative, then what is the best way for me to do that? (I.e., should I list the journal title? should I indicate what stage it's in?)
3. How do I cope with the anxiety associated with waiting to hear back from the journal? Any tips, advice, suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
4. Lastly, what does it mean to have a paper under external review at a journal at the Masters stage? (I know that there are many people who have done this, but I just don't know any of such people personally, and so I was hoping to get a better, general sense of what this whole publication thing means at this stage in my career/life.)
Thank you so much in advance!!
First of all, best of luck to the OP with both the paper and PhD program applications! In terms of their questions, I'm not sure about (1), (2), and (4), as I don't know how much can be inferred from a paper being sent out for external review at a journal. Then again, I've never served on a PhD program admissions committee, so I don't have any inside insights on matters like these.
In terms of question (3), I don't have many tips for coping for anxiety other than this: I try to put submissions as far as possible out of my mind. One must always remember that selective philosophy journals tend to have rejection rates of around or over 90%, and peer-review can take many months. So, unless you want to remain stressed out, my suggestion is simply to try to focus on other things. That's what I try to do, at any rate!
Do other readers have any helpful answers for the OP?
Leave a Reply