In our most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

Is it acceptable to list serving as a reviewer for a textbook as "service"?

I would like to mention it, as it seems to support that one has at least a certain standing in the field, but I also don't really know if it actually does support that.

It wouldn't have occurred to me to think otherwise. This obviously seems to me to count as service, though I guess in principle it may depend on how one's university faculty handbook defines service.

What do other readers think?

Posted in

4 responses to “Textbook reviewing as service?”

  1. a referee

    I have a section on my c.v. devoted to refereeing. I list: journals refereed for (and how often); book publishers refereed for (and how often); granting agencies refereed for (and how often).
    This clearly (to me) belongs in the book publisher list. (I assume the OP means refereeing by the term “reviewer”)

  2. In the Service section on my cv, I have a subsection for Refereeing and Reviewing. For an entry like this one, I would list it as “Publisher’s reviewer for [Title], [publisher], [year].”

  3. Michel

    Refereeing of all kinds definitely counts. (I wouldn’t count blurring though!)

  4. MPA

    Yes, this definitely counts. I distinguish between types of reviews, e.g., “full book manuscript review for publisher X” versus “book proposal review for publisher X” and so on. Reviewing an entire manuscript takes a long time if done right (often seeing revisions), so it’d better count as service!

Leave a Reply