In most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

How do internal hires work in the U.S.? I've noticed some people starting jobs at universities without the positions being posted (at least to my knowledge).

Hmm…I was of the understanding that jobs need to be posted for legal reasons (presumably to satisfy EEOC requirements). However, I'm not a legal or HR expert, so I'm mostly speculating and don't know how far those requirements extend. Is posting the position on the university's job page enough? Or, do universities need to post job ads more widely? If the former is the case, that might explain the OP's observation. But again, I'm not sure.

Do any readers have any helpful insights to share?

Posted in

9 responses to “Internal hires without “posting” jobs?”

  1. in the know

    I think there are many ways that internal hires happen in the USA. As Marcus implies, the rules around where jobs have to be advertised are not so specific. So jobs can be advertised quite locally. Indeed, I assume that many (but not all) community colleges do not advertise in national venues. I know of one case where a department did not advertise for a TT position because they hired a person for a one year job the previous year, and then hired that person the next year for a TT job, and the administration said there was no need for a natonal search because the department had done one for the one year position. (this is perhaps a warning for those who think it is not worth their while to apply for one year positions … or to take such jobs).

  2. Anony

    I am not sure if this is what OP is referring to, but I have seen places that keep up a single job ad for when they need to fill teaching gaps. These ads are sometimes up for years.
    Depending on the place, these jobs might technically be called “Lecturer” positions. And then there is a chance that this role can turn into a more full-blown Lecturer position with a full course-load. I have seen this happen with a few people in my area.
    (To be clear, some of these have been internal hires, but others have not.)

  3. International

    For international scholars, universities must conduct searches to sponsor them for permanent residency. Consequently, they open the search for just one day, and the candidate applies within hours. They are not interested in hiring another candidate, but they are still compelled to do the search.

  4. resentful

    TBH, I’d prefer internal hires to just be internal. Sometimes there are fake interviews. You prepare for them. You don’t get the job. And the feedback is so obvious that they didn’t even pay minimal attention to what you’ve said in the interview.

  5. anon

    The requirements for posting ads that I can remember off the top of my head flow from collective agreements, which leaves room for variability between institutions, and even more so if they don’t have a collective agreement with their academic workers. Maybe there are national requirements that I’m not thinking of, would be curious to hear.

  6. Tenured now

    At my (private, R1) university, you can do “target of opportunity” hires. These are positions created for specific people who they are offered to, and they are not advertised anywhere. I believe there is also a specific category of hires that involve people who have been in a temporary position for several years being hired into a permanent position without a search.

  7. SLAC Associate

    I’m not a lawyer, but my understanding is there are next to no national laws about whether and when jobs need to be posted, except for (a) certain federal government contractors who must take affirmative action to make jobs open to and available to military veterans and (b) when hiring international employees who will need to be sponsored for a visa.
    That said, if organizations aren’t careful in how they fill positions they can set themselves up for a situation where they’re sued for disparate impact against a protected class, and so many organizations have adopted requirements that jobs must be posted in so many places for so long in order to show they’re taking actions to preclude racial or gender discrimination in their hiring practices. But even in organizations that have relatively strict hiring practices, exceptions are regularly made for promoting existing employees into similar roles. Most relevantly for this blog, to use “in the know’s” example, it’s not terribly uncommon that a department can take someone who was hired into a renewable lecturer role (after a broad search) and get approval to just “promote” them into an open tenure-track line without too much fuss.

  8. Tim

    I’m familiar with multiple cases, with more than one university, where they don’t post on philjobs but rather post on higheredjobs. And the post is up for a few business days, like 3-5, before its taken down. If OP isn’t signed up for higheredjob alerts, they might miss those (not that OP or anyone should apply for them since they are already taken).

  9. Here’s a case

    I know of a case where a state regional school did an ‘internal search’ within their state school system, which satisfied the requirement to advertise.

Leave a Reply