In most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

I've finally won the job market and got a tenure track position. But somehow, I'm feeling down. In part, I feel like an imposter that is going to be caught soon. Moreover, I feel guilty for getting what others deserve or deserve even more. Are there other people who had similar experiences? How did you deal with it?

My sense is that this is pretty common, particularly among early-career academics (see work on the settings where impostor syndrome occurs). I definitely had a similar experience early in my career, and honestly the best I could do is to simply work through it, focusing on improving my work (in research, teaching, etc.)

What about other readers? Have you had similar experiences? If so, any tips for the OP?

Posted in

9 responses to “Feeling like an impostor in a TT job?”

  1. It’s normal

    I think it is quite common. I work in the UK, in a pretty good department. I always feel that my colleagues have better papers, bigger grants, and wider networks, and I fear that they might think the worst of me. One day I had a conversation with a senior colleague and, despite their incredible achievements (really amazing!), I could sense they feel some kind of impostor syndrome, maybe for senior profiles. Anyway, this is something you should learn how to manage, because it rarely goes away completely

  2. Without exaggeration I think about 80% of academics feel like this. I would deal with it the way you deal with other baseless negative feelings. If you don’t have any good way of dealing with baseless negative feelings, consider speaking with a therapist.

  3. Frank

    This worked for me, but may be idiosyncratic: I felt like an imposter from my first undergraduate philosophy course, through grad school, post-doc positions, the tenure track, and still do as a tenured professor. At some point, I decided that I was never going to really be a successful philosopher. But it occurred to me that I am an unbelievably successful imposter. I’ve pretty consistently fooled some of the smartest people in the world and conned my way into a career where I get to read, write, talk about, and teach philosophy – all of which I love more than I do authenticity.

  4. grant

    You are not alone, Frank!
    I went to a mid-ranked program, and I did not work in a popular area. I got paid poorly in graduate school ($1000-$1500 per month for 9 or 10 months with no summer funding), and my travel fund in graduate school was $300 per year. At some point I just came to realize that I could not compete with someone at the top program whose advisor was working on trendy topics and who got huge financial packages. (Literally, some friends were in Europe for several workshops during the summer when I had to work to support my family.) There was just no way for me to be as good as them.
    But then I also realized that we were trained to think of philosophy in terms of research, but that is only one aspect of an academic job. Your teaching, your personality, your experience, all matter in visible and invisible ways. So, OP, do not feel that you got what others deserved. Others might have published a lot more, or have more teaching experience, but you have something they do not have, and you deserve 100% what you got.
    Now I am tenured. I accept that I probably will never be a successful philosopher qua researcher. Nobody cares about my work, and I know very few people at conferences. I often feel that I just do not belong to the profession. But being a philosopher is more than a researcher. I read things I like, and I teach interesting classes. Life is not too bad.

  5. Acceptance

    Good feelings do not necessarily follow good events. Feelings simply do not follow such simple logic. You can use the “guilt” to motivate your work (and help others if you feel strongly), like what Marcus said. And I think feeling good all the time is overrated anyways.

  6. Michel

    I might be wired differently, but for me, once I started getting some accomplishments under my belt, it went away.
    The biggest and most significant one was the PhD, because whatever else others might think, that was a huge project and I pulled it off successfully, meaning (in my mind) that I was at least minimally qualified. Whatever else happened, nobody could take that accomplishment away from me.
    Once I racked up some publications and got a permanent (if NTT) job, those just helped to feed the sense that I’m every bit as qualified as anyone else. Now, I just never worry about it any more.

  7. It helped me to reflect on the fact that we are, collectively, quite bad at determining who is doing work that will be important 5, 25, or 200 years from now and that I am, individually, almost certainly worse at this than we are collectively. So my judgments about whether my work is worse than so-and-so’s are almost certainly just utter trash. I should take them about as seriously as I take a typical first-year undergraduate’s assessment of whether utilitarianism or deontology is correct.
    It’s also helped me to reflect that, on any reasonable timescale, the difference between my work and the work of anyone I might reasonably compare myself to is basically zero. Neither of us is doing anything that will be remembered for a long time.

  8. on the tt

    Two things helped me with imposter syndrome. I think Daniel Weltman, above, is right that most of us deal with these kinds of thoughts.
    First, I decided that it was somebody else’s problem, not mine. If they didn’t realize I was a fraud, I might as well get away with stuff while I could. Hopefully that is about 30 years. (This attitude is related to Radhika Nagpal’s Scientific American post, “The Awesomest 6-year Postdoc.” I recommend checking that post out! I will confess, though, that the post did not change my thinking so much that I started applying to TT positions at places like Harvard.)
    Second, yeah, you probably don’t “deserve” the job as much as someone else “deserves” the job. Whatever “desert” is, the job market doesn’t track it. And even if it did, there just has to be more than one deserving candidate for the whole thing to come down to luck, anyway. You’re not deserving; you’re lucky. (However, you are probably qualified, too!) Happily, doing the job doesn’t have much to do with “desert,” just with being qualified and putting in the work. And perhaps if you do that, you’ll become deserving. But even if you don’t – wow! You’re still really lucky you got to do that!
    Like Frank, these may be too idiosyncratic to be helpful. But then again, this discipline is full of idiosyncratic people.

  9. Other Frank

    I am an imposter. This doesn’t mean that I can’t contribute to discussions, whether in publications or at conferences. But it’s a veritable house of cards. Like Frank, I’m okay with that at this stage.

Leave a Reply