In our most recent "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

This may be a unique question, but I'm thinking of writing a book on a topic that I haven't published on extensively as an academic philosopher. (In short, the topic is much more applied, and in an area in which I used to do advocacy work).

Will my book proposal be met with extra skepticism unless I publish 'academically' on that topic? Do you think concerns would be mitigate by making clear my relevant work/teaching experience?

Stories from those with first-hand experience most welcome!

I'm not sure. What do readers think? Any readers have relevant experiences to share?

Posted in

2 responses to “Publishing a book in an applied area one hasn’t published in (yet) academically?”

  1. If it is a trade book (for a wide audience, not just academics), you need a good proposal and often a platform (an existing audience of people who will buy your book). Your standing in the academic subfield may not be a significant factor. Trade publishers will often judge that a philosopher is sufficiently qualified to write on a philosophical topic for a general audience. Having advocacy experience in the area will add some credibility both to the author’s standing and the idea that the topic is one for a general audience.
    For an academic book, experience in the subfield may be a consideration, but it isn’t paramount. (I published an academic book having had only one journal article in its subfield previously.) The quality control mechanism isn’t track record but the publisher sending the full manuscript out for peer review before final acceptance.
    Highly recommended: Laura Portwood-Stacer, The Book Proposal Book.

  2. OP

    OP here: just picked up the Book Proposal book! Thanks so much for the rec.

Leave a Reply