In our September “how can we help you?” thread, a reader asks:

I’d like to know the extent to which the prestige of one’s PhD-granting institution (or even master’s or undergrad) affects hiring in the very top UK and US universities. I struggle to find examples of people graduating from less prestigious universities getting postdocs or jobs at these more prestigious universities. This is unfortunate in the UK in particular, as even if you get accepted into a more prestigious university, funding is rare and some cannot self-fund. Would people who have sat on hiring committees have any insights or impressions on this matter?

The late Helen De Cruz (R.I.P.) published some good work on this in 2018. As discussed here in 2020, there do seem to be pretty serious prestige effects across the academy:

  • Eric Schwitzgebel found in 2019 that elite philosophy PhD programs mostly admit students from elite undergrad institutions, and that only 11% of students in the elite PhD programs he studied were from institutions not nationally ranked in US News & World Report.
  • Helen De Cruz found in 2018 that philosophy PhDs from low-ranked departments rarely secure employment in high-ranked departments.
  • This 2015 study found steeply hierarchical inequality in faculty hiring across three disciplines, with just a quarter of all universities accounting for 71 to 86 percent of all tenure-track faculty in the U.S. and Canada. The study also found that “18 elite universities produce half of all computer science professors, 16 schools produce half of all business professors, and eight schools account for half of all history professors.”

That said, I am sure there are exceptions. Are any search committee members able to weigh in to share helpful insights?

Posted in ,

9 responses to “PhD dept. prestige and hiring in the US & UK”

  1. dazesensationallye39c0dc2cd

    When I’ve sat on searches, this trend was sometimes bucked. It tended to happen when the search was in history or something else that required mastery of texts obscure to the rest of us or a similar scholarly skill that can be demonstrated independently of other credentials. Less so the less scholarly, and more “armchair analytic,” the AOS sought (e.g. ethics, meta-ethics, analytic metaphysics, phil language, phil mind).

  2. Anonymous

    OP here. Thank you for the replies. I just wanted to make my question clearer: How much of a bias do we think there is towards/against candidates just due to the prestige of their university? Or do we think that the patterns can almost completely be explained by the fact that the strongest candidates just tend to hail from the more prestigious universities? I appreciate that the answer to this question can only be pretty speculative, relying on anecdotal data, but I suppose I am feeling desperate/looking for hope.

  3. Anonymous

    As OP indicates, the situation is so much worse in the UK, where you might well get the offer from Oxford but not come from a rich enough family to attend grad school there. The complaints about the “hierarchy” of the US system are positively quaint compared to UK academia’s literal class system. From this side of the pond, US PhD funding is a miracle of social mobility.

  4. Anonymous

    It is relatively easy to collect data on this. Here is where the permanent faculty at Harvard got their PhDs: 5 from MIT, 3 from UC Berkeley, 2 from U Wisconsin, 1 each from: U Mass Amherst, Yale, U. Michigan, UC Irvine, UC Riverside, Cambridge, Pittsburgh, Cornell, Univ. of Penn.
    It seems the “lowest” rank institutions are 27 on that somewhat famous ranking, the name escapes me.
    I doubt that you would find anything different from any of the other top 20 universities.

  5. Anonymous

    My impression for the UK – not based on any data and so maybe entirely false – is that it matters a lot for Oxbridge, LSE and a few others, but much less for most other universities. Indeed, pretty much, if not all, of the philosophers I’ve met who are one of the more recently-hired lecturers in their department weren’t from Oxbridge, Yale, Harvard, etc. We’re a middling UK university and have hired several people over the past 7 or 8 years. None had PhDs from the supposed “elite” universities. Each time, as a hiring committee we didn’t care a jot if your PhD was from Sheffield, Kings, Sussex, Oxford or whatever.

  6. Anonymous

    Some observation: some UK institutions hire disproportionately their own graduates, not just OxBridge. I have very strong skepticism about such practices though. I would think it extremely unlikely that one’s own phd just happens to be the best out of hundreds of applicants.

  7. Anonymous

    Following up on Marcus’s pointers, I have recently done the same prestige analysis as De Cruz on updated 2015-2025 APDA data: https://apda.ghost.io/2025-survey-res/
    -Kino

  8. Michel-Antoine Xhignesse

    Back in 2015, I counted up (note: not a rigorous statistical analysis or anything, just brute counting) where everyone then working at ranked programs got their PhDs, and published it as a post on the Cocoon: https://philosopherscocoon.com/2015/03/27/the-composition-of-ranked-programs/

    Just five departments accounted for 34% of placements. Just 2 departments accounted for 15% of all placements. My recollection is that the amount of self-dealing (hiring of own graduates) was very high at Oxford and Toronto; somewhere else, too, but now I don’t remember, and the data is on a different hard drive. One of the Ivies, I think.

    Anyway, this seems to bear out more rigorous analyses from other fields which show that just a few programs take the lion’s share of placements. I do not believe the selection explanation, because my experience is that the top-notch students everywhere are, well, top-notch, and they seem fairly well distributed. I do think that differences in funding, supervision quality, and departmental culture add up over the course of a PhD, giving those at fancier programs a cumulative edge when it comes to the job market, at least on average, though probably not at the top end. I don’t think this is a sufficient explanation of their research placement sucess, however.

    Anecdotally, it seems to me that students with fancier degrees do better on the market. Certainly, here in Canada, if you do a postdoc at Oxbridge (which is entirely doable, thanks to SSHRC and FRQSC), you’re in a much better position than someone who did theirs at a Canadian institution (probably also than anyone who did theirs at an American institution other than Harvard/Yale/Princeton); and a fancy American postdoc is more valuable than a “fancy” Canadian postdoc (if there are comparably fancy Canadian institutions, which I’m not convinced is the case; Canadian academia really values the foreign credential).

  9. Anonymous

    This isn’t an answer to OP but more of a PSA. It’s there I think, but there are many exceptions, I have seen many, so don’t get too defeatist if you are currently not at a top-ranked program. I teach at a relatively presitgious UK university and it genuinely doens’t seem like something we base decisions on (yes i recognise that if it’s an unconscious bias that is perhaps what i would think even if we did base them on it)

Leave a Reply