In our September “how can we help you?” thread, a reader asks:

Is it okay to list a publication in a journal without noting that it’s in a special issue or special edition or symposium (but still peer-reviewed)? I realize that doing so is less than fully revealing about the pub, and that in asking the question here I’m calling attention to that fact, perhaps thereby inviting a more disapproving response. But I ask folks to please try to look past that, and just imagine seeing it listed as a publication in that journal (on a CV or website), and then later learning, through some other means, that it was in a special edition. Would you then judge the author as deceptive or shady, even if the piece was fully peer-reviewed and accepted by the journal?

Thoughts from readers?

Posted in , ,

12 responses to “Should CVs flag publications that are part of a special issue, etc.?”

  1. Michel

    It used to be normal to do this. But also, it used to be that most special issues were basically invited pieces with no real peer review.

    Most special issues now are properly refereed, and the submissions are anonymized. So I don’t think we need to mark them out any more. It doesn’t look like most people are, and I have followed suit in not doing it myself. I do mark out invited contributions that don’t go through anonymous peer review.

  2. Anonymous

    I don’t think it matters, so long as it was peer-reviewed as normal articles would be. It used to be more helpful to flag it, when special issues were mainly invited and not peer-reviewed, and were also physical copies so you would hold an issue and see several papers all on a topic, see who else published in that issue, etc. (which is less easily done when everything is published online, and less often do people discover what else is published in a particular issue). I myself wouldn’t care if I discovered someone’s article in Synthese or Phil Quarterly (etc.) is in a special issue (and Synthese does a LOT of special issues).

  3. Anonymous

    I guess it depends on how the article got in. When i was a special editor (phil studies) a few years ago, it was no less rigorous than the regular process. We got blind reviewers to give their views and on their basis, and our own judgment occasionaly, accepted or rejected papers, and plenty were rejected even though they were invited to submit. If that’s how your issue worked, then I think marking it out on your CV as a special issue would seriously undersell yourslef, since some special issues are not peer reviewed, or the peer review is pro forma.

  4. If a publication is invited, I think that should be indicated. But I have no preference with respect to whether people note that something is in a special issue otherwise.

    1. Anonymous

      Why should that be indicated? Especially when the vast majority of more senior faculty never make notes on their CVs of which of their publications were invited. I think so long as it goes through what looks like the standard anonymous review process, one need not make special notations of whether invited (especially because doing so ends up tacitly allowing the overly scrutinizing observer to possibly discount a publication for dumb reasons… with respect to those folks, you’re never going to win their approval anyway).

  5. Anonymous

    I use parenthetical comments before the bibliographic info to make things as clear as possible. For example:

    (invited for special issue: refereed) “Article title,” Journal, etc.
    (refereed; co-authored with XXX, my contribution was 65%) “Article title,” Journal, etc.
    (invited chapter) “Chapter title,” Book Title, editors, etc.

  6. Anonymous

    Frankly, this is just the sort of thing that I notice when I am reviewing job applicantions. It is a small form of deceipt, but it tells me that if we hire this person they will not be a straight shooter. I expect that I will always have to check what they say. They will be deceptive with students, with colleagues, with the administrators. I have worked in this business long enough to know that these small things are really reliable indicators that someone will engage in other forms of deceipt. I am currenly dealing with a senior colleague who is deceptive, a colleague who I have worked with for almost 10 years … I do not need to hire a new junior colleague of the same ilk.

  7. Anonymous

    I think you should just flag it as a special issue contribution. One reason is that it might situate the paper. Special issues are quite focused, and so, the nature/impact of your paper may be highlighted better if it is clear that it is in a special issue on topic x. I also think this flags you as an expert, or leading name, of topic x. That’s a good thing.

    On my cv, I mark invited pieces as ‘invited and peer-reviewed.’ I’ve contributed to volumes and special editions upon invitation, but in all cases the papers have been reviewed. So, I just like to make clear that, while the piece was invited, it was still peer-reviewed.

  8. Anonymous

    When people worry about this or want the special issue to be marked, due they mean that it should be marked as a special issue in a parenthetical or asterisk or some other notation like that? Or do they mean that the publication should be listed according to CMOS / APA / MLA’s recommended form of citing a special issue, like here for CMOS: https://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/book/ed18/part3/ch14/psec077.html

  9. Anonymous

    Only one experience of reviewing for special issue here, but from that I would like them clearly marked out.

    So here’s the first part: for invited special issues from workshops, it is possible that it is an almost automatic pass for desk rejection. Normal papers have to at least persuade the editor that the paper is worth sending out for external review. And then it is the slight but existent pressure of “oh I invited you so it may look nasty if I were to reject you.” At least that’s how I feel. Reviewed a paper for a special issue, the paper was really bad, like assuming that racism is correct level of bad, and arguing for a conclusion that I perceive to be rather racist. So how would I treat special issue papers from that journal if I were on the committee? How would I treat candidates who don’t mark out special issues from that journal clearly?

  10. Anonymous

    As others have noted, I think all that matters here is whether the paper went through the normal peer review process.

    Similarly, it’s common to distinguish papers that are peer-reviewed from ones that are not, e.g. invited chapters in books, either by putting them in separate sections, or somehow flagging non-peer-reviewed ones. I would just take the same approach here; flag it as invited (or something similar and accurate) if it wasn’t peer reviewed, but if it was then I don’t think you need to do anything special.

    In case it’s relevant, I have some publications in special issues that went through the normal review process. I have never flagged them or heard any indication that I should flag them.

  11. dazesensationallye39c0dc2cd

    Original OP here. Thanks so much for all the responses. Super helpful and informative!

Leave a Reply