In our September “how can we help you?” thread, a reader asks:

What’s going on at the Australasian Journal of Philosophy? They’ve had one of my manuscripts for too many months. When I inquired after four months, I was told that it hadn’t even been assigned to an associate editor–the very first step. Several peers of mine have similar stories. I replied to ask about the median time to first decision, but the question was unsurprisingly ignored.

Judging by the data from papers recently published there, it seems to take a minimum of a year to get through their review process, and often two. One recently published paper took *three years*.

This strikes me as completely bonkers. Does anyone have more information about what’s going on at that journal? Do they have any sense of urgency about this, or are they twiddling their tenured thumbs? It’s hard not to think I should withdraw the manuscript if I find out it’s still not with external reviewers. Advice welcome.

This is a surprise to me, as I’ve always had very good experiences with the journal and had the sense that it has a good reputation for fairly quick turnaround times. Maybe, like other journals, they are dealing with vast increases in submissions (e.g., due to AI)?

Do any readers have any helpful insights to share?

Posted in

32 responses to “Delays at AJP?”

  1. Anonymous

    I have no insight into the internal workings of AJP – I can only offer my own anecdotal experience. I received an R&R after ~5 months from the journal. Like OP, I had reached out to them after four. I was told that they had just secured a second reviewer, and expected to have both reviews within a month (which they did). Perhaps I’m jaded by the academic experience, but 5 months no longer seems unusually long to hear back about a first-round decision for a submission (though three years does strike me as exceptionally long!). My best guess – and this really is a guess – is that the development of AI has resulted in academic journals being swamped with submissions; editors are struggling to keep up with the huge volume – many of which were largely generated by AI.

  2. Anonymous

    I noticed this as a reviewer for them recently. I submitted my review report and then it took the editor another 4-5 months to get a decision to the author (I checked back a few times because I’m looking forward to citing the paper in my own work). This could of course be for a multitude of reasons, including the tardiness of the other reviewers, but it did make me have second thoughts about submitting my own work there.

  3. Anonymous

    I have found them to be quite slow– I can’t recall precisely but like 5 months to initial move, 5 more months after the submission of an R&R and many months after that to get formally accepted.

  4. Anonymous

    I’ve had a paper there for 3+ months with no change in status beyond “submitted”, though of course I’m aware that this status does not always reflect what’s really going on.

  5. Anonymous

    I thought that it is normal for AJP? I submitted a paper (I believe) in 2024 and it took 13 months to get a rejection verdict. The reports were extremely detailed and helpful though. Since then I always take AJP to be a journal that delivers fair judgments and good reports (which are so rare these days) but you have to expect to wait.

    1. Anonymous

      I’m glad you got good comments, but 13 months is just not acceptable. If the philosophy of science journals can get final decisions in a few months and most other journals within 6-8, there is absolutely no reason that it should ever take 13 months to get what I’m assuming is a single set of referee reports. Stories like yours make me think AJP has a unique problem.

      1. Anonymous

        Anecdotally, I think that this is also a common problem with Phil Studies (8-12+ months for an initial decision, sometimes with just one referee report). I’m not at all suggesting that this is acceptable, but I fear that the problem is not as unique as one might hope.

      2. Anonymous

        I am the anon who posted the original comment. Yes I agree of course that this is unacceptable.

        But echoing the other anon’s experience with Phil Studies, I too waited for over nine months for multiple submissions to get a (rejection) verdict from Phil Studies. And the reports are extremely unprofessional and brief; they are so bad that I stop considering Phil Studies as a serious journal.

        And that’s also why I said at least you get quality reports from AJP…

  6. Michel

    FWIW, this is the first I’ve heard of such delays there (though I haven’t checked on the status of things I’ve reviewed for them reently); historically, they’ve been very good about fairly quick turnarounds. I’ve never had to wait more than three months for a verdict.

  7. NonTT

    I have submitted a paper to AJP in April and I am yet to get a decision. I sent my paper to them in no small part due to their reputation for quick turnaround. I inquired twice to find out what happened, once after 4 months and again one month later. The first time I was told that they still haven’t sent it out for review. After asking about it a month later, I was told that the first review is due within a month. To be fair, I have also had a good experience with them in the past, when I received a thoughtful rejection (with some helpful comments) very quickly.

    This raises a related question for me. Whom should I reach out to? I’ve been in contact with the editorial assistant who told me that an editor will follow-up with me. (They never did) Is there anyone I should reach out to next? Is it the editor-in-chief?

  8. Anonymous

    I’m in the same boat as OP. I submitted a paper in April, and was told in early September that the editor hadn’t assigned an AE. Interested to see what other people say because I’ve also been wondering if I should pull it!

    1. Anon

      Same here. I submitted in mid-May, and after four months I inquired about the status of the manuscript, only to be told that an AE would soon be assigned to look for reviewers.

  9. Anonymous

    When I got a quick desk rejection from them last year, I was under the impression that AJP was a model journal for quick turnaround based on what I read on DN and elsewhere. It is surprising to me to read these comments. Perhaps relatedly, on the APA survey site, recently someone posted a comment about their experience with PPR: “unusual delay – ‘We are experiencing a sharp increase in the quality and volume of submissions.’” I am personally waiting for another top journal to get back to me after an extended delay.
    I guess at some point I would really appreciate it if the major journals’ editors could get together and share some insights with us concerning how things have evolved.

  10. Anonymous

    I had a paper under review with that journal for more than one year. I sent them an email 5 months after my initial submission and I was told that they were waiting for the first report. They secured the first report in month 7 (or, at least, this is what I was told from the editorial assistant — I haven’t seen the report). I then waited for the second report for several months: the report never arrived. I sent periodical inquiries to the editorial assistant and the answer was always this: “the second report is due next month”. I reached out to the editor in chief 12 months after my initial submission and I never got a response from them. I withdrew the paper around 13 months after my initial submission.

  11. I submitted back in July 2025 and received a rejection with comments from one reviewer by September 2025. Around the same time a friend had submitted there and waited four months just for a reviewer to be assigned, not sure how long it took for them to get a verdict/comments. So if there has been an overall slowdown, either my submission was handled with exceptional speed, or the slowdown has only developed in the last year.

  12. Anonymous

    I’ve had a paper there since June, which, of course, isn’t as long as some people here have mentioned, but is still unacceptable. Maybe there’s a good reason, idk, but, whatever the reason, it’s puzzling that no one has been appointed as acting editor.

  13. Anonymous

    Previously, I’ve had good experiences with AJP. But I recently pulled a paper because they hadn’t found a reviewer after 8ish months, and the editors were unresponsive to email. (The editorial assistant is responsive, but the editors seem to ignore you). I think it’ll be a while until I submit anything to AJP again.

  14. Anonymous

    I too had a horrible experience at AJP. They took 8+ months for an initial verdict. Inquired after four months, was told that they hadn’t had a single report, but had one referee secured. At about six months in they told me they had two reports. And then the Associate Editor sat on the two reports for another two months (!) before issuing a verdict. Editorial Assistant told me that the “editorial office is closed” for the Australasian summer, so all I could do was to keep waiting.

    Well, if the journal is closed every year for two months so the AE will not issue a verdict despite having all the reports, perhaps that’s a piece of information that prospective submitters should know!

  15. Anonymous

    To add another data point: I find AJP extremely erratic. Last year I had a very quick turnaround from them – 1.5 months to rejection after one review, which I think is admirable. This year (2026) a paper that I sent in April has been just languishing – four months and the story is exactly as the OP mentioned (not yet sent to AE). Not quite sure what to make of this.

  16. Anonymous

    This is all just anecdotal, but it recently took 7 months for me to receive a rejection verdict from AJP, at my latest submission. This was after I sent an email, inquiring about my submission, after 6 months. While I’ve previously had quality comments at AJP, this set of comments gave me the impression that the referee had hardly read the paper. I know of somebody else who waited over 8 months to get desk rejected from AJP, within the last year. These turnaround times are unacceptable, in my eyes, and I will likely submit to other journals over AJP in the future.

  17. Anonymous

    one more data point: I have had a paper under review at AJP since November 2025. I inquired in June, and was told they were waiting for an initial referee report. For what it’s worth, my experiences at AJP have almost always been positive in the past (even with many rejections). I guess they are going through something at the moment.

  18. Anonymous

    It would be really useful if someone at the AJP could weigh in on this!

  19. Anonymous

    More anecdata – I submitted a paper in mid-June of 2024, and got an initial verdict just under 6 months later. Submitted the revision and got an acceptance after 2.5 months. Those times seem fairly reasonable to me, but it sounds like things have gotten a lot worse since then.

    (FWIW, it DID take 18 months between the paper being accepted and them sending me proofs – but they did tell me that it could take that long.)

  20. Anonymous

    I’ve heard that AJP practices depend hugely on which associate editor involved. Some are truely awesome. Others, not really. So I just see submitting to AJP as rolling a dice on whether I can get one of the good associate editors.

  21. Anonymous

    Could anyone share what areas of papers have particularly slow associate editors? I have a history paper that I am working on (early modern) that would work well for a generalist journal, and I was thinking the AJP, but it does not look like they have published any history papers for a while.

    1. Anonymous

      My 8-month-initial-verdict paper is in ethics/political philosophy.

    2. Anonymous

      For me and my friends (in total 3 samples) social and political was slow.

    3. Anonymous

      If you have a history of philosophy paper then it is best to place it in a highly ranked hirstory of philosophy journal rather than a generalist journal. The best work in the history of the philosophy of science is published in HOPOS – everyone working in that area knows this. The situation is similar in other areas of history of philosophy.

      1. Anonymous

        I already have papers in the top history of philosophy journals. I have a permanent job already. Generalist journals have higher Q numbers, and are more “ref”-able. This matters in a European/uk context.

  22. Anonymous

    AJP are changing their editorial board – the AAP recently advertised for applications to be the new editorial team – I know of at least one strong team that applied. I hear that the existing editorial team were completely swamped, this is probably made worse by the pretty serious issues at Adelaide University. So I would hang in there. I would expect the issue to be sorted pretty quickly now.

    1. Anonymous

      Is this to say that reviewing is currently halted?

  23. Anonymous

    Just saw that there’s a new editorial assistant at AJP. Is this related to what Anonymous of Oct. 10 says about the editorial board? I’m curious because I’ve had a paper under review there for 8 months.

Leave a Reply