In our September “how can we help you?” thread, a reader asks:

Is there a risk that people on search committees might take applicants’ “next project” ideas, run with them, and try to scoop the topic? I’m curious how specific or general you should be when describing your future research agenda in job applications (research statement), especially in highly competitive, “trendy” fields like the philosophy/ethics of AI.

Especially if you’re not a grad student but someone in a TT position trying to make a lateral move? I mention this because if you have a grad advisor and faculty and other people who know your current work, they might be able to vouch for you in case someone does try to scoop you, but as a faculty member in not well-known departments and you yourself aren’t well known, it seems like it’ll be nearly impossible to argue. And given the state of our discipline, more senior or mid-career but well-known people seem to get the benefit of the doubt more often than others.

I would certainly hope this doesn’t happen. Is this a real risk? If so, what’s the best way to manage it? (Please note: the Cocoon is not a place to make/air accusations–comments to any such effect will not be approved).

Posted in ,

16 responses to “Search committees scooping applicants’ ideas?”

  1. Anonymous

    I don’t know if this would happen. It seems to me very unlikely. But I don’t know. However, just like with the possibility peers stealing your ideas, my advice is just live your life, discuss your work freely, and be merry. The costs of being guarded and suspicious steal so much joy and opportunity as well, that you should just consider it an occupational hazard.

  2. Anonymous

    God if this were a thing we should just burn the profession to the ground and be done with it. Fortunately, I have never heard of this being a thing.

  3. Anonymous

    two reasons to think it isn’t a very big risk:

    1) many departments are looking to hire someone to fill a research gap, meaning they are less likely to be able/want to successfully scoop a candidate’s idea

    2) in large departments where 1 does not apply, often the search committees are quite large and several people read files, disincentivizing someone from stealing an idea that was read by several people to belong to someone else

    of course, it could happen that a search committee member, in the preliminary stages of reviewing applicants, is the only person to see a research statement, and decides to steal an idea. but in my experience of having to review 50+ applications very quickly, typically I am not reading research statements closely at this stage. When I am, I am FAR more interested in reading about what they have *already* published (to see if they have a solid record of publication)

    so all in all, i would say the risk is very low

  4. Anonymous

    I am always quite surprised seeing this kind of concerns, though this is nothing personal against OP. People typically have way too many projects to work on rather than too few. I routinely decline collaborations (that come with free ideas). Also, it is rare that other people’s projects exactly interest you. Even if something strikes me as super interesting, I would be too lazy to steal *their* ideas, which requires publishing earlier (?), rather than building on their ideas. And of course, there is the ethical sense that I am not a thief. So this kind of questions just sound odd to my ear. But again, maybe it’s just me. I don’t even lock of my bike in public.

  5. Anonymous

    While it is not quite the same thing, there have been comments on previous posts from people on job committees saying that they take pedagogical ideas from the things that job applicants write in their teaching philosophy, etc. I’m not saying that such a thing should never happen (generally I think that the more sharing about teaching methods the better), but as someone who has been on the market for the last several years, it doesn’t feel great to hear people on job committees openly admitting to poaching teaching ideas from applicants they decide not to hire.

    1. Anonymous

      I guess I don’t see “taking pedagogical ideas from the things people write in their teaching philosophy” as ANYTHING like “stealing their research project.” Maybe I don’t know what kind of insanely specific thing you write in your teaching philosophy but:

      a) I think most people describe pretty generic things (break students up into small groups, have them collaborate on classroom norms, or even “flip the classroom” or “have students design a video” or something like that) that couldn’t really be “stolen” because they just clearly aren’t really special to that person.

      b) insofar as someone had a totally novel idea (I dunno- have students design their own video game using theory x or something? I think Jason Brennan had some kind of specialized business ethics teaching ideas he was giving people? ) i suspect people use the idea they were inspired by in a teaching statement much more generically like “that made me realize I could have my students do art projects or design a boardgame or something.” That’s much closer to research than anything like concerning plagiarism (it’s like hearing someone say “I am making x claim about promising” and you thinking “oohhhh promising sounds like a cool area” and then reading up on it and developing their own view.

      c) teaching just seems like a more collaborative thing. Its something we are doing as a service to students, the world etc, its not proprietary. And its not about individual attribution really. It would be fine if we all did the same thing if it turned out to be what works best. Whereas research is clearly attributive and includes a long history of citing people. (I don’t cite the first class I was ever in that broke up into small groups when I do that for my students and I don’t take myself to be wronging whatever professor taught that class. I don’t really know what it would mean to cite a teaching idea.)

      d) I would be surprised if this happened much though I’ll take your word for it that people have said they did it. In my experience, a very large number of people will admit to never reading teaching statements (even if they care about teaching! What people say about teaching is questionable evidence for how excellent they are at teaching.)

      e) I am sure that would feel terrible. But for what its worth (and I’m an n of 1, I know) I’ve never heard of someone being hired or not hired based on a teaching statement (like I said, I’ve heard a lot of people say they don’t read teaching statements and an equal number of people say they barely skim them or read them at best for the absolute finalist and even then only to look for red flags.)

      1. Anonymous

        As I said in my initial comment, I don’t regard it as quite the same thing and I generally think that sharing teaching methods is a good thing, so, so far we are in agreement. Mostly, as stated, I was expressing how it didn’t feel great to me. If the most innovative pedagogical idea one can think of is breaking students into small groups or do an art project, then it isn’t surprising that one wouldn’t think that even such a feeling is justified.

        I’ll just note that I have been advised to be as specific as possible in my teaching statement and to avoid generic claims. The interviews I’ve managed to get have often asked me specific things about my teaching statement, and some of the short term positions I have been hired for (a year or less) have told me in conversation afterwards that it was the teaching strategies discussed in my statement and the interview that led to them hiring me. Considering that many of the places I am interested in being hired by place an emphasis on teaching, I think I will continue to consider the teaching statement as a potentially important document.

    2. Anonymous

      This is a very surprising student. If there is a better paedagogical method I almost feel it would be wrong (to your students) not to steal it. The main problem I see with plagiarism is that it harms the author, and that just isn’t the case when you take someone’s ‘teaching ideas’.

      1. Anonymous

        Okay, let’s imagine that a department realizes that they need to renew their teaching strategies in the face of mounting student dissatisfaction. They are relatively clueless about how to do this, so they decide to put up a fake job search that places a special emphasis on teaching documents. They do not intend on hiring anyone, they just view this process as a way to collect new and innovative teaching ideas that have been worked out by others. According to you, there is nothing wrong with this process.

        If the worry is about the initial deception, we can tweak the initial set up a bit. Let’s say the department repeatedly tries to hire a new line but for whatever reason the search keeps failing. Let’s say that there is such a high likelihood that the search will fail that there isn’t really any point in running the search. However, the department finds itself in the need of teaching renewal and knows that it will likely get a bunch of exciting and innovative teaching ideas from the the applicants, so they decide to run the search…

        To be clear, I am not saying anything like this ever happens, only that according to the previous post, there is apparently nothing wrong with this situation. As suggested by another response, if an applicant were to find out that this was the case, they shouldn’t even feel remotely upset about it because teaching ideas are meant to be shared/stolen so the process doesn’t harm the applicant in anyway.

  6. Michel

    I’ll just echo people above: (1) your research interests are probably not reflected in the search committee or hiring department in the first place, (2) there are lots of eyes on the file, (3) very, very few people would be so-inclined in the first place, and (4) your work is already at an advanced stage; it would take a while to put together a new paper that wasn’t just obviously plagiarized

    And yeah, I think the more normal situation is to have more ideas than we can write up, rather than a dearth of them.

  7. Anonymous

    I agree with the general sentiment – I’ve not heard of this happening. But: to follow up on Michel’s point (4) – keep in mind that a good “next project” idea is generally one that is already worked out. That is, ideally, you already have a draft of something for your “next project(s).” If you don’t, it can be hard to describe a “next project” in any reasonable amount of detail that makes it sound plausible, significant, and interesting.

  8. Anonymous

    I know that all my my ideas are so brilliant that everyone is probably itching to steal them. But I doubt that is a problem for most philosophers.

  9. dazesensationallye39c0dc2cd

    I’m puzzled by some of the resistance to the idea of “scooping” in philosophy reflected here. In the natural and social sciences, where I spend some time when I’m not doing philosophy, nobody would deny that a finding that P, for the explanation/reason that Q, would be hard to publish if someone else just prominently published or presented the same: a finding that P for the explanation/reason that Q. The reason is obvious: P isn’t news, or much of a discovery, if someone else already discovered and disclosed it, nor is the proposed explanation or reason for it. Why should it be different in philosophy? The only reason I can think of is that maybe philosophy doesn’t produce noteworthy truths and noteworthy reasons or explanations for them. If that’s true, then I agree with the commenter who said maybe we should just pack up shop.

    1. Huh

      I don’t think what you are describing is remotely related to what the commentators were describing. Say a job candidate says that they are going to show that x. Unless someone was literally plagiarizing a job candidates paper, it’s not like you just publish “I conclude that x.” You would need to actually develop the arguments and write the paper. The candidate would almost certainly ly be ahead of you (and anyway do it different than you since evidence is more idiosyncratic In many of our subfields). And somehow do this without your colleagues who talked to the same person noticing. It’s a bit like say in the lab sciences where you would need to come up with the experiments and run them before you could claim to have “found” anything. Thats not an argument there are no truths, just that conditions make scooping less of a thing and less likely in a job candidate situation than say a random bar conversation.

  10. dazesensationallye39c0dc2cd

    Right. But see my first sentence and what I said I was puzzled about: “resistance to the idea of ‘scooping’ in philosophy” that I detected in some of the comments, even though, yes, the thread’s main focus was a specific scenario, which I gather you’d have preferred I discuss. Sorry to tangent; at least I was explicit about it.

    1. Anonymous

      Sorry- to clarify, I meant that I don’t think scooping in the sciences is the same thing. In *some* science fields there is a whole media industry around “first past the post” ie the first person to show that x. This is especially true in the drug industry where patents are quite literally set up that way in the United States. Because journalism is complex, sometimes saying you found that x might be enough. I’m honestly not sure how much scooping is a thing in the sciences (in lots of areas it might not be– you still have to get a grant, get access to the right instruments/materials/data/study group etc, then conduct the data collection or whatever, and you would almost certainly be behind a person who had already gotten started. I’ve never heard my friends who are scientists express worry about being scooped, but then maybe they aren’t up for nobel prizes.) But I don’t think it (mostly) makes structural sense in philosophy, except MAYBE at the margins in the few cases where an idea is mostly about claiming territory in a new AREA or question rather than a careful argument. And even then there is usually room for more than one because the evidence/argument/detail might be different in a way that matters. But I don’t think that the structural features that makes this not very much of a worry in philosophy provide reason to worry about the existence of true discoveries.

Leave a Reply