In our newest "Ask a search committee member" thread, 'early career anon' writes:

If an applicant has chosen to work in a number of different areas of interest and is less specialized in one particular AOS than other candidates, how should they go about presenting that in the best light to search committees?

Although it's not entirely clear to me what 'early career' means here, I take it the case may be something like this. Suppose one's primary research programs are on free will, philosophy of perception, and vagueness–a number of different areas not unified under a single AOS. In that case, I assume one may list one's AOS as "Metaphysics, Philosophy of Mind, Epistemology, Philosophy of Language." However, one's actual areas of research are much narrower than those broad categories suggest. If one is applying to, say, a job ad in Metaphysics, one will come across as 'less specialized in Metaphysics' than many other candidates (since one only does one thing in that area, free will). Assuming this is the kind of case 'early anon' is concerned about, how should a candidate like this pitch themselves?

I'm glad 'early career' posed this question, as I think it raises some important issues I haven't heard discussed very widely. First, although I could be wrong about this, I suspect that having really narrow areas on focus (say, free will or philosophy of perception) may work against candidates–unless they are (A) really good in those areas (viz. securing an R1 job), or (B) they also have significant training in, teaching experience in, and have published in other areas in the listed AOS. The reasons why I suspect this are two-fold. On the one hand, I have personally known candidates with really narrow areas of focus who have struggled on the market more than I would have expected, given their publication records. On the other hand, having a really narrow focus can intuitively restrict one's appeal. Suppose you were on a search committee hiring in Metaphysics, you're not particularly interested in free will, the philosophy of perception, or vagueness, you have other candidates in your pile who specialize much more in Metaphysics in general, and your department is looking to significantly expand its course offerings in Metaphysics specifically. In this case, someone with really narrow but diffuse areas of focus (free will, perception, vagueness) might not much appeal to you compared to someone with broader training and interests in Metaphysics. Anyway, I could be wrong about this–so I'd be curious to hear from job-marketeers with narrow specialties whether they think this has set them back on the market, as well as from search committee members (do you prefer candidates with broader research focuses to really narrow ones, all things being equal?).

In any case, I suspect that the best way for such a person to pitch themselves to search committees is to indicate in some way that they have significant training and research interests outside of their core areas. I say this having read some really narrowly-pitched research statements that leave it unclear whether the person does any work outside of their core areas. Every time I've read a research statement like that, it comes across strange to me–raising doubts about whether the person would be interested in or well-prepared to teach courses outside of those areas. Anyway, that would be my advice: to make it clear in one's cover letter, CV, research statement, and teaching statement that one is interested in and prepared to teach other courses squarely in the AOS listed in the job ad. But these are just my thoughts. What are yours?

Posted in ,

2 responses to “Pitching ‘narrow’ AOS’s to search committees”

  1. Some of these AOS aren’t really all that narrow. E.g., those who do phil perception often work with the related psychology and neuroscience, which means they actually cover a lot of ground. Second, this naturally leads to an AOS list that looks like “phil perception, cognitive science, philosophy of neuroscience, etc”, which isn’t all that narrow but doesn’t fit nicely under a label like “phil mind” (traditionally construed). Third, if you have a “narrow” (but actually merely disjointed according to standard taxonomies) AOS (e.g., phil perception) and are applying to a job advertised as something broader (e.g., phil mind) where the intent of the ad is to get someone who is really up on all the traditional research in that area and where there’s little room for you to spread out into your related areas (e.g., cognitive science), then it just sounds like the job isn’t a good fit for you. Finding a way to pitch yourself to this job sounds at worst deceptive, and at best like a bad idea: I imagine the search committee will see through it, there will be others who are manifestly better fits, and (even if you got the job) you wouldn’t actually be happy. Likely you won’t know the real intent behind the AOS listed, so perhaps it’s still worth throwing your application into the pile, but it then seems best simply to have a CV that’s transparent, highlights your accomplishments, and is organized so as to bring out some relevant theme or narrative. E.g., if you have in fact taught a lot of traditional phil mind courses (or whatever), put that down (of course). (This is also probably a reason not to clutter your CV with a line for every little thing you’ve done, so relevant work is easy to spot.) If you’re a fit, you’re a fit?
    To be clear, I don’t think Marcus is advocating being deceptive.

  2. Philosopher

    I second what Michael said. Maybe one can boil it down to: if your AOSs are at all non-standard, make sure you have the bog-standard AOCs in the related areas.

Leave a Reply