In our new "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

A teaching-portfolio question for all, but especially recent search committee members:

What stood out about good teaching portfolios in your applicant pools? How many pages, syllabi, and complete course evaluations do you recommend including? How many of each are too much or too little? What are some things no one should ever do?

I know teaching portfolios have been discussed here and elsewhere in the past, but I find that disciplinary norms change from year to year, and I'm also dragging my feet in trying to figure out how to improve my own teaching portfolio. So advice would be appreciated.

All three are great questions. Are any readers (particularly those who have served on search committees) willing to weigh in?

Posted in

10 responses to “What stands out to search committees in a good teaching portfolio?”

  1. good luck with it!

    Here are my thoughts, on the receiving end of these:
    -do not try to include an outline for every possible course you might be asked to teach. Rather, include representative outlines (three?) – obviously they will be more compelling for the courses you have actually taught.
    -do not include reams of course evaluations. First, they are meaningless unless read against others’ scores from the same institution. Second, they will never be read. Include maybe two or three courses, and only a summary.
    -ABSOLUTELY, do not include your own unofficial evaluation that you conducted. Yes, people really do this. Of course it looks bogus and that you are trying to hide the real thing.
    -keep the teaching philosophy/statement simple. You won’t get hired by saying your classroom is like a circus, and everyone is having fun, and totally challenged, etc. Just tell us what you do, and what works (works = results in effective student learning)

  2. The teaching portfolio is a document trying to serve too many purposes. My advice for job applicants is to keep it simple, and keep it short. Long documents, especially info dumps like pages and pages of student comments, will likely not be read.
    The first page is the one most likely to be read, so pack it with the most useful information, clearly and efficiently displayed. That is:
    (1) A chronological list of courses taught (including TA/co-taught/instructor of record, level, subject, whether for majors or gen ed, modality, number of students per section, number of sections, date range). (You can use two or three columns as needed so this list doesn’t take up too much space.)
    (2) A list of any pedagogy training (specify courses, workshops, conference sessions)
    (3) A list of any pedagogy research (workshops delivered, conferences, publications)
    (4) A table summarizing teaching evaluation ratings, one line per section taught, ideally with a comparison class like university average, department average, average for this level of course, or similar). Since evals are of dubious evidential value, don’t over-think this part: Just present the top-line data.
    A lot of places demand a Teaching Statement or similar, so make that the second page. These should be as concrete as possible, with examples of actual things you have done if possible. Typically you get brownie points for active learning, cultural sensitivity, being open rather than dogmatic, rigor with scaffolding to help students meet your standards, accessibility/universal design for learning, assessment procedures and feedback for learning, scholarship of teaching and learning, promoting philosophical virtues, and similar. Don’t include all those things. Also typically good is integrating one or two quotes from student comments that confirm that students enjoy and learn from those things you are describing about your teaching.
    When I see folks include too many syllabi for prospective courses, I get a bit suspicious. Include a good syllabus of a course you have taught. If the ad says they need you to teach a specific course or subject, include one for that. Maybe one more for a new course you would like to introduce. Everything after the first can be a sketch of a syllabus (topic list, sample texts, assignment structure) rather than a full-blown many-page document with all the syllabus apparatus.

  3. unofficial eval

    @good luck with it, when you say some people include unofficial evaluations that they conducted, what do you mean exactly? Would this count?: We had a strike towards the end of one semester and couldn’t conduct official course evaluations. I (along with several other grads at my university) sent out an anonymized google form to my students with the usual official questions. In my portfolio, I included the top line data from these evaluations on a bar graph with the rest of my evaluations, but with an asterisk noting the above.
    This all seemed pretty normal to me at the time, but now I’m a bit concerned that if there’s a more nefarious/cringeworthy practice in the ether, what I did might get unconsciously lumped in.

  4. Bleh

    Ha! As soon as I start getting exceptionally good teaching evaluations in each course (including supplementary unofficial evaluations) I find people saying that they aren’t taken very seriously/seriously at all/shouldn’t be included.
    I suppose the positive is that it would have been even more discouraging to know this before being motivated by doing well on them.
    I hate the job market.

  5. good luck …

    Yes, people do “run their own” evaluations, and then send the results. I have seen applicants send them as part of their application. How do I know, because I know where they work, and what the real evaluations look like. There is far too much “gaming” going on.

  6. Genuinely Curious

    I’m just curious about the discouragement towards attaching student evaluations of teaching because more and more job ads in the last couple years have been asking for them (and sometimes just them without any of the other elements of the teaching portfolio). Most of my successful applications to short-term positions have come from places that have just asked for teaching evaluations with a cover letter and CV. For that reason I started attaching them to all my teaching portfolios, but I’m now getting the sense here that that is probably a mistake?

  7. Two-Curious

    Genuinely Curious,
    I’m also curious, especially since some ads are ambiguous about including them (“If candidates want to include evidence of teaching excellence” etc.) so it would be good to have a sense of what at least some committees want.

  8. I don’t want to speak for everyone in the field on teaching evaluations, but here are some generally accepted (I think?) worries about them.
    The instruments are different at every institution, so you can’t really use the results to compare candidates. There are many well known factors that bias results, including the instructor’s gender, the discipline of the course, even the specific course, levels of technicality and rigor, student prior preparation, student prior interest in the subject, whether we are talking about a major course or a gen ed course, a required course or an option, local trends at some institutions, and the list goes on. There is a great deal of unexplained variability of results (e.g., the same instructor in the same term may get wildly different ratings across different sections). Factors unknown to search committees can radically affect results (class size, attendance rate, survey response rate, when in the semester the eval was given, whether it was in class or online, etc.). In short, it is not clear what teaching evaluations measure, if anything, and since they are not comparable across job candidates, they can’t (shouldn’t) carry much weight in hiring decisions.
    Student comments are sometimes helpful, except they are subject to strong bias in that usually only students who are especially happy or especially upset leave written comments. Many unhappy students also drop the course before the eval, so there’s a bias there, too. So committees have to read student comments with a grain of salt (is that how that saying goes?).
    For these reasons, most universities I know do not give student evaluations of teaching much weight in tenure evaluations. They are included, but mostly looked at just to confirm there are no screaming problems, to check that the tenure candidate is “good enough” at teaching, and (best result) the evals show steady improvement with experience. Evals are one component of assessing teaching quality, and other elements (teaching materials, teaching statement, peer teaching reviews, etc.) typically carry more weight.
    What does all this mean for TT job candidates? Include student evaluations by all means, but make sure the rest of the materials in the dossier make the case that you are an adequately good teacher. It is probably better to type up a page of “selected student comments” that captures what is good about your teaching and confirms what you say about it, than to include pages and pages of copies of the written comments. You can do the latter, of course, and it is not exactly a mistake, it just diminishes the chances that the full teaching dossier will be read. But as a committee member I’d rather see the former with a note to the effect “full student comments available on request.”
    The story is somewhat different for adjunct and temporary positions, where department chairs often make hiring decisions based on a c.v., a teaching eval or two, and a conversation. There’s not much at stake from the university’s perspective when hiring someone to cover one or two courses, so the chair just needs to check that the person knows the material and is probably acceptable as a teacher.

  9. CW

    FWIW from Professor at Regional State U:
    1. We ask for complete evaluations from recent courses. We’re less interested in how you did in the past. We also don’t want summaries.
    2. I don’t put too much weight on course evals because they are subject to plenty of biases, but some of my colleagues will comb through them, looking for red flags. Also, most candidates receive excellent scores from students.
    3. I’ll take a careful look at syllabi, especially for courses we want you to teach. Few syllabi stand out but most are reasonable enough. There is huge overlap here between most candidates, so it’s not easy to stand out.
    4. Interesting assignments can catch my eye. I’ve borrowed a couple over the years.
    5. Nonstandard or otherwise interesting reading lists can catch my eye, as long as you stay in the realm of philosophy.
    6. I want a clear statement of how many courses you’ve taught on your own and what they were. I’m less interested in hearing about TA work or prof/ta shared courses.
    7. I don’t read teaching philosophy statements. We don’t ask for them but sometimes receive them.
    8. I’m not too worried to learn that the students you’ve taught are different from mine demographically. I’ve worked at a couple of different schools and adjusted my approach as necessary. I assume we can help you do the same. That said, if you get an interview, my colleagues will describe our student body and ask how you would work with them, so give it some thought if you get past the first round.
    9. I’m somewhat interested in which of our courses you might like to teach, and what sorts of courses you might want to add to our curriculum. I say “somewhat” because the reality is that this sort of change can take some time to happen.
    10. It is difficult to stand out in the area of teaching. Many candidates are simply very good at it.
    11. This won’t surprise you, but I’m looking for someone who has successfully taught the courses we want taught. Try to make that clear above all.

  10. Two-Curious

    TW and Bill V.,
    Thank you both, much appreciated!

Leave a Reply