In our job-market discussion thread, readers have been discussing the costs of Interfolio. One reader wrote:

Some of us use interfolio for letter uploading. I know this is probably beyond the capacity of philosophy search committees, but if not, please ask for letters at later stages of application. a) You probably won't read any of them until later stages; b) each uploaded letter actually financially costs the applicant.

(The paid basic subscription to interfolio allows us to upload letters 50 times, then we will have to buy more quotas.)

Other readers provided some counterpoints, such as:

FWIW I think people in many (maybe most?) searches read letters even on the first pass (at least skim them). While I'm sorry for the costs to candidates, I personally find letters really valuable on even a first pass (I know there's variety in this and also disagreement about whether they are just noisy, but, at least at the extreme ends of the spectrum, my experience is that they are NOT just noisy.)

And one reader pointed out that Interfolio only seems to charge for some ways of sending letters but not others:

Just since the cost, of Interfolio deliveries was mentioned above, I thought I'd emphasize: when a candidate bundles up some files and has Interfolio send those files as an "email delivery" to a specific address, it shows up as a "free email delivery" in their account history.

(this is how it goes for me, anyways)

By contrast, when an application system has various little slots for email addresses of my letter writers, and when I input an email address and Interfolio sends them a letter, this is what makes the paid credits total go down and eventually cause a person to get more paid credits.

So it comes down to whether HR forces you to do things the second way. The first way is better.

This has been mentioned before, maybe even on Letier reports. But it seemed to me that some of the above commenters may not have been aware, so I thought I'd put it out there.

In any case, I wanted to amplify the issue, as hiring committees may not be well-aware of these issues. I seem to recall some online discussions of Interfolio in the past suggesting that hiring committees consider steering away from the service for these kinds of reasons, but maybe I'm misremembering.

If anyone would like to discuss these matters further here, please do comment below!

Posted in

12 responses to “Interfolio costs and the job-market”

  1. For people using Interfolio, I think it lets you do Interfolio applications for free (i.e. not counting as your 50 letter uploads). My institution (among others) uses Interfolio for our applications, so hopefully the 50 letter delivery limit is not a worry for people applying to places like my university and others that use Interfolio. If I’m right about this (I think I am, but I’m like, 80% sure) then hiring committees for places that use Interfolio don’t need to take this into consideration.

  2. confusions

    Hi, just some clarifications:
    (a) often hiring committees have zero control over what system they are using.
    (b) that being said, if people want to cut down on costs for candidates, they SHOULD use interfolio to host positions. I haven’t rechecked this, but as of a couple years ago, sending letter deliveries was free if the search was run through interfolio.
    (c) Marcus, just to make this clear: It is not the hiring side that is costing candidates money. For example, if a candidate doesn’t use interfolio (PLEASE DON’T DO THIS TO YOUR LETTER WRITERS) it is never going to cost them money to send letters. It’s the job seeker’s use of the service that is costing the job seeker money. So, with the exception of (b) above, there’s nothing that can be done on the hiring side except not asking for letters at all, or delaying asking for them. Except:
    (d) I could be wrong about this, but I seem to remember that some other job hosting sites, e.g. AJO, allow you to store your letters there (so you only need to make one delivery to the AJO system ,and then if you are applying to multiple jobs within AJO you can just select your letters within the system). But again, could be misremembering on this part.

  3. tradeoffs

    In my opinion it’s a cost/time tradeoff. Hosting the entire application through interfolio reduces the applicant time by orders of magnitude (from maybe a 25 minute exercise in toto to around 5 minutes). But the cost totals to about ~8$ per application.

  4. To confirm what others have said, in my experience the department has had no choice but to use the application system owned by our university, and very little control over which items we want to ask for, when.
    HR treats it as an equity issue: All candidates must be evaluated by the same evidence. So we can’t request letters after making an initial cut. Functionally that means we typically have in fact only considered part of the file for most initial decisions (equity be damned, I guess), looking at the whole of a file only for cases where there’s controversy before zoom interviews, then reading everything for everyone who gets a zoom interview.
    I remember the good old days, where we had to photocopy our entire application file (not including reference letters, of course) and send it by mail to each department to which we were applying–sometimes multiple copies to a given department. Candidates requested letter writers to send mail to the same places. The hiring departments then had to collate all that mail from multiple sources arriving at various times, and manage filing cabinets full of paper for each search, including sign out sheets to keep track of who had each file for review. Good times.

  5. I’m confused

    @tradeoffs: I don’t understand your comment. Isn’t it free to send interfolio letters to an interfolio hosted position, as described above?

  6. Mike Titelbaum

    Here’s a further thought, from the other side of this process: Over the past week I have downloaded, one at a time, each of the 840 applications UW-Madison had for its search. (Remember what everyone said above about departments’ having no control how their application systems are set up?) Of those, the ones that used Interfolio mostly had at least three letters included. The ones that didn’t use Interfolio mostly didn’t have at least three letters. We certainly don’t hold it against applicants whether their letters are in on-time—we figure that’s up to the letter-writers. So our administrators are now going to spend the next two weeks chasing down missing letters. My point, though, is that Interfolio seems to be a much more effective letter-management system than other alternatives. I don’t know how to balance that against the cost to applicants, but I thought this was worth applicants’ knowing when they make their choice.

  7. Craig Agule

    My first thought as I read this thread was that Interfolio was just the cost of doing business for being a grad student. While money is stretched thin as a grad student, and while it would be great if every institution used Interfolio, life is not ideal. This is a pain for grad students, but it is one of the least of the pains.
    But my second thought: you know who could be bearing some of these costs? PHD-granting departments. Given that this is the cost of being on the market, PHD-granting departments are probably the best choice to soak up some of the costs between individual grad students, the hiring schools (many, and indeed most, of which have far fewer resources than most PHD-granting programs), and the PHD-granting departments.
    Is this a sophisticated, reflective thought I’ve arrived at after long reflection and investigation? No. Does this overlook the many even-more precarious applicants who already have the PHD in hand? Yes. So, add those qualifications.
    But if you’re a DGS reading this post, it might be worth considering whether the department budget has enough money to reimburse Interfolio costs for a year or two or something like that for grad students. Even if my thought is most wrong, as long as it is a little right, you might be making life a little bit better for a few of your students. (And maybe departments are already doing this?)
    (And, again, this is just a first thought—so probably there are a hundred complications I am not aware of!)

  8. VAP

    In response to Mike, I don’t think that almost any applicant would prefer the option of not using Interfolio at all. We all recognize that Interfolio is a valuable resource that we are willing to pay some money to use. The issue on the table right now is only how to reduce costs for applicants. One way is to host applications on Interfolio itself, since those applications don’t cost applicants anything. Another way is to have applicants use Interfolio to email letters to a specific email address (say, the chair of the search committee or perhaps an email address created specifically for the purpose of gathering letters during searches). This way, applicants can send all their letters for (what I believe is) only one delivery credit. What we are concerned about is the system in which applicants input the unique Interfolio email link for each letter into a system that then requests each letter individually. If an applicant sends three letters that way, it takes three delivery credits, rather than one (as in the direct email method) or none (as in the method of hosting the application on Interfolio).
    As far as I can tell, if the university requires that departments use a non-Interfolio-based application system, then the question is whether to use one of the other two methods I’ve mentioned. The direct email option is cheaper for applicants, but I would assume that it would create more work on the department since letters would have to get matched up with applications somehow. It then just becomes a question of whose interests to prioritize. Maybe for jobs that get 800+ applications, it would be reasonable for the hiring department to insist on doing whatever is easiest for it. But perhaps for jobs that are likely to get fewer applicants, it would be nice to have the option to send all letters in a single email. And, of course, if the choice between these two methods isn’t up to the hiring department at all, then so be it.

  9. michaela m

    @Craig yes I think (many?) departments now do this. We do it at BU and Princeton did it when I was a grad student there.

  10. It is a thing

    @Craig @michaela Columbia does it too.

  11. Very Grateful

    The outstanding administrative staff in our department upload our letters. We are given a number of dedicated email addresses that all feed into the same inbox and then we indicate the jobs we’ve applied to in a shared spreadsheet. It’s an imperfect solution to a highly inequitable system. I didn’t realize how good we have it and would encourage other departments to implement a similar system if they are unwilling to reimburse.

  12. Emails are free

    I know this is old, but to clarify, it’s free to send Interfolio letters to an email address. This seems to be the best option for departments who cannot afford to run the job search through Interfolio itself. Search committees, please do this more!!

Leave a Reply