In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

I know that one or two recent job market candidates (for example Elise Woodard) have shared examples of their successful materials, and I was wondering if there was anywhere a compendium of others who've done the same. I find the concrete examples exceedingly helpful for writing cover letters & research/teaching statements (significantly more so than generic advice).

Does anyone have any examples (or a compendium) to share?

Posted in

26 responses to “Examples of good job-market materials?”

  1. mossy

    Although a bit dated by now, the sample job market documents in Kathryn Hume’s Surviving Your Academic Job Hunt: Advice for Humanities PhDs is still quite useful and I would recommend that for samples.

  2. Oudemia

    Zoë A. Johnson King (Harvard) also has her docs uploaded to her website.
    Do we know any male philosopher who also shared them?

  3. Taking someone else’s “successful” materials as a model for one’s own sounds good, but do be careful not to overinterpret the model. There are many reasons that someone might have been successful, reasons that might or might not have been related to the way their cover letter or cv was constructed. Fit (primarily AOS/AOC vs department’s stated and unstated teaching needs and tastes) and perceived philosophical acumen (primarily through the lens of “will they earn tenure here”) are the main things that get someone hired. Another way to say this: the same materials might be successful in one case but not in lots of others.

  4. I am happy to share my materials with anyone, though with the important qualifications that Bill V mentioned above.

  5. anon

    the goat, Zoe Johnson King.
    One caveat: Her materials are probably tailored toward elite, elite institutions. So, take that with a grain of salt when you read. E.g., your research statement probably does not need to be anywhere near what she has (unless you’re applying to elite, elite institutions. In that case, godspeed)

  6. curious

    @anon I am really curious, what is the difference between materials tailored to elite institutions and materials tailored to non elite ones?

  7. curious2

    @curious, I would assume that it’s the number of papers that are planned. Johnson King had 13 papers planned for publication. Woodard had 9. Also, Woodard links to Angela Sun, also from Michigan and has documents shared (do only people from Michigan share documents?) and had 9 papers planned. I’m curious how many planned papers do people who normally get jobs have, elite vs. non-elite, and how important is the number vs. the details.

  8. me?

    curious2,
    Just to be clear, “papers planned for publication” count for nothing in job searches.
    That is, you can have 9, 13, or 0, and it will not affect how your file is evaluated.
    I think it is best (just me, man), that you save “planned” publications for your conversations when you are doing an on-campus interview.
    For the same reason, papers under review count for 0.

  9. Placement person

    Just want to say, as someone who did placement for many years: do not copy these people’s materials. The times my students’ initial drafts of things have been the absolute worst is when they copied Zoe’s materials. That doesn’t mean it didn’t work for her, obviously it did (though we have no way of knowing if that is in spite of or in part because of her materials; if someone is a golden child of philosophy, it won’t typically work for others to just imitate them!). But seriously my biggest advice as long term placement director: do not imitate others’ materials.
    Also agree about this “papers planned” thing—it’s weird and will backfire for most people, I think.

  10. Confused now

    Wait, so now I’m really confused. At my school we are encouraged to give a unifying story about what ties our work together in a way that makes clear that there is mileage in it for future work, then abstracts of work in progress with some remarks about where our work will go in future. Is this an instance of “papers planned” that would be bad? What else are research statements supposed to be (for ABD and recent graduates) if not that?

  11. But what do i know

    I’m not that far along. But my sense is that nobody thinks “papers planned” are much in the way of evidence that you will actually write and publish those specific papers. (Just like grad school admissions essays are not great evidence of what you will actually have as your dissertation topic.) HOWEVER, some of the things you would say in talking about papers planned in a research statement can point to a substantive and thoughtful future direction of your research which, when combined with evidence of existing writing productivity and publications in that area, can provide reason to believe that you have a strong pathway to creating a research pipeline moving forward (even if the actual pipeline ends up looking different than the one you said was planned.) So basically, nobody will take your actual descriptions of future papers that seriously, but they will care that you have sensible sounding things to say about where you might heat .

  12. not what got them the job

    I submitted a reply to this that I don’t think was published, but I’ll try again: The people in question who post their job materials were successful on the market for a number of reasons that go well beyond the specifics of their job app documents. It would be a mistake to infer that the specifics of these materials are what got them their jobs! For this reason it’s always irked me a bit when people post their job docs like this, since it does send that message…

  13. Oudemia

    @Placement person, I think nobody in this thread talked about “imitation.” Needless to say, if you are imitating someone else in your job market materials, you are missing the point about, well, the job market.
    @Confused I include future papers to share what I am working on. Since I am about to present them at different venues (my CV says so), why wouldn’t I include them in my research projects?

  14. just publish?

    I’m also confused. I was told that the research statement was future-directed and supposed to lay out a plan for future research, maybe several years ahead. Should it instead be a backward-looking document summarizing past work, so what matters is just a great track record of publications?

  15. first-time candidate

    Right – though I am not experienced, I have also received lots of advice to the effect that the point of a research statement is to show that you have a reasonable plan for extending your current research project into future publications. I don’t see how you could do this if you don’t mention planned or in-progress papers. I can see why some places might regard this speculative and thus irrelevant to evaluating a candidate, but I take it that those are the same places that don’t ask for a research statement. In any case, I have certainly not received any kind of feedback to the effect that mentioning planned papers is taboo or cringey. Of course, lots of different kinds of people are on search committees, with lots of different avenues to being turned off by a candidate. Maybe this discussion is a good reminder of that!
    Also, quick point in defense of successful candidates who have posted their materials — I do not think that by posting their materials, they are saying, “Copy this formatting and you’ll be successful”, or “I got the job because I said X in Y part of my materials.” They posted their whole files, and surely a big reason they got great jobs was because of how impressive their whole files were. That is consistent with the thought that any one part of their file could have been non-ideal. But being on the job market and putting all these materials together without having a clear idea of the criteria on which they’re evaluated is stressful — in light of this conversation, it’s easy to wonder if there are any secret rules or taboos — and it can reduce stress when you see a concrete example of successful materials.

  16. me?

    It is me? again,
    For junior hires (tenure track), what “we” wanted to see in a research statement was a more general statement of where you want to take your research in the future. It should typically make some sort of connection with your past research (even if that is just your dissertation). For example, “whereas my dissertation concentrated on addressing the threat posed by various versions of the pessimistic meta-induction to scientific realism, I now plan to articulate a form of selective realism that does not fall prey to the charge of supplying only post hoc explanations. Part of this project will involve analyses of historical cases from late 19th C physics and chemistry. blah blah blah …” If you merely list a bunch of planned papers you are allegedly going to write, it is not clear if (i) they are already written in part, or (ii) you are just dishing up a bunch of stuff you will never deliver on (and never could). Ideally, the committee will see that the candidate has articulated a project that looks sensible, given the background they have, and what they have in fact accomplished to date.

  17. Bar Luzon

    I uploaded my materials to my website, and one can find them here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1p8NK7D1Kh9wKBEzbhxPcATM0aYJiqsTO?usp=sharing.
    Obviously, what worked for me won’t work for everyone. But the thing is, it’s really hard to get a sense of what one could write in such statements if one sees no examples. (Writing samples and dissertation summaries may be obvious enough, but research and teaching statements are not at all obvious, nor are cover letters.) And although it’s true that just copying a single model without reflection is a bad idea, it is a very good idea to look at multiple models and choose among them on the basis of particular considerations (how systematic one’s current work is, how many ideas one has for future work, how worked out these ideas are, what jobs one is aiming at, etc.). I learnt a lot more from examples of this sort and particular comments on my drafts than I learnt from any piece of general advice. (Except for maybe this one: one’s cover letter should be a summary of one’s greatest hits.)

  18. original poster

    I just wanted to chime in by thanking the folks who’ve shared materials, whether their own or others’. I agree I certainly can’t imagine it’s very much use to copy materials directly, considering the goal is to present your file rather than someone else’s. But, I asked this question because, for me, exemplars are useful for getting a better sense of the soft norms for presentation & content, the sort of stuff a savvy advisor might be able to tell you, much as reading philosophy papers is ultimately the only way to get a sense of how to philosophers write.

  19. Consensus?

    I second the OP, these examples are very useful. My department advised that research statements should strictly be no more than 2 pages and teaching statements just a single page…. however, those documents are longer in the examples circulated in this thread. So, is there a consensus?

  20. context sensitivity

    @Consensus? I wonder if breaking norms like having longer statements and writing mostly about planned publications are fine as long as you happen to be coming from an elite institution with all-star letters because in virtue of that search committees may implicitly pay more attention. But if you are not, then the best strategy is to have punchier, shorter, and less ambitious statements. I’d be interesting to see sample materials from successful candidates coming from non-elite institutions.

  21. re consensus

    Conesus is hard to find in any aspect of the philosophy job market. But yes, I think creeping above those limits is fine if you have something good to say. Not very far, though.

  22. anon

    am I right in thinking that these sample research statements serve for folks doing comtemporary stuff? I have the impression that res. statements of those working in history of phil. are somehow different (e.g. you are not expected to ‘develop’ a theory)

  23. anon

    @Consensus? Remember, many of these materials come from candidates applying to elite institutions (think top 5 PGR). Many of us are not going for these; we are often going for SLACs. In that case, we should take a different strategy of the sort Marcus discusses in the Job Market Boot Camp series.

  24. anon

    I really do not understand why non elite ones do not require (as the suggestion goes) detailed research statements etc. Can someone please explain?

  25. The Real SLAC Prof

    @ anon and other confused ABDs:
    The primary example people are focusing on was somewhat unique because she outlined a large number of papers she planned on writing in the future. Also, at the time application, she actually had zero publications. Some of these planned papers were clearly in draft form already and others seem to be more ideas than actual drafts at the time this was written. She makes it very explicit in her statement which of the papers she was willing to share in draft form. She also makes it clear how her planned papers related to her dissertation.
    I think what some people want to say is that having this many planned papers is unusual, and attempting, in one’s research statement, to outline this number of future papers could be counter-productive for many applicants. Many people would be better off focusing on outlining how their current work fits together and outlining fewer future papers, especially if the future work is not available in draft form.
    I don’t think, nor do I think anyone means to imply (I hope),that you should have one research statement for SLACs and another for R1s; nor do I think “elite” people should approach their research statement one way, while “non-elite” people should approach it another way.
    Instead, I think this thread brings out a fundamental truth: there is some disagreement about what, exactly, an excellent research statement looks like. I assure you that there is similar disagreement about all other application materials. There is also disagreement about how important the research statement is in comparison to other aspects of the file, i.e., the cover letter.
    I think current candidates should look at some examples (thank you generous providers of examples!), and depending on the specifics of your file (e.g., do you already have multiple publications? are these publications in different areas? do they hang together? do you have many ideas about future work?) you should craft a research statement that presents you in the best possible light. If you don’t yet have many publications but you have ideas for a bunch of draft papers, maybe your materials will look like the exemplar, whereas if you already have several publications, maybe it will look somewhat different as you devote more attention to explaining how your published work hangs together.
    I don’t think the success of anyone’s candidacy is going to turn on the precise structure of the research statement. For whatever it is worth, I mostly use them as a way to orient myself to the writing sample and the CV. I have sometimes used research statements to help me generate questions for interviews. I do pay more attention to the stated plans for future work than I do to the overview of past work. I’m looking for someone who can clearly explain the significance and trajectory of their research. And sometimes when this explanatory work has been done well in the cover letter, I don’t look at the research statement at all.

  26. Hello all — I’m late to the party, but this inspired me to post my materials from last year (when I applied successfully for my current job at William & Mary), in case anyone is interested. Link is here: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/i0twoiq2u04etp029kaq0/AAV0aPYRBnDRFIKOJrrJe8c?rlkey=wmth5fh3x5mocdutyz20xc06v&st=db5vmv3i&dl=0
    I’m a bit of a weird case, though — I graduated in 2017 and had ~2.5 postdocs before my last year on the market. But I hope this reassures someone a tiny bit that it’s possible in principle for a lower-ranked program grad to find a good job at a research-friendly institution.

Leave a Reply