In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

Does anyone know what the major Medieval Philosophy journals are? Or a resource for ranking (though I understand the great limitations to ranking)? I not so much asking about the main History of Philosophy journals, but specifically the "area" journals for Medieval Philosophy. Thank you all!

I don't work in history of philosophy, so I have no idea. Do any readers?

Posted in

3 responses to “Major Medieval Philosophy Journals/Rankings?”

  1. helper

    There is a generic way you can find an answer to such questions. Pick a few leading researchers in your sub-field, and then look where they place their best articles that are published in journals.
    This method would invariably lead a philosopher of science to take note of Philosophy of Science, BJPS, and Synthese.
    But more to your point, though I don’t work in Medieval, I know Vivarium is highly regarded.

  2. American Medievalist

    The hierarchy is less clear in medieval than it might be in some areas, in part because medieval is so much more international than some subfields, with so many of the top scholars being in Europe and publishing in languages other than English. There’s also just enough of an ideological split between the Thomists and non-Thomists about what’s important in the field to further complicate matters. But as an American and non-Thomist, my read is that Vivarium and Oxford Studies in Medieval are easily the top two specialist journals, and I think that isn’t too controversial of a take. I’d even say that publishing in either of those is just as (and maybe more) prestigious than publishing in most of the generalist journals that have substantial medieval coverage (BJHP, HPQ, Res Philosophica, etc.). JHP is the obvious exception to that general rule: a medieval publication in JHP is nearly as good as it gets.

  3. Agree with helper and American Medievalist. I’d add that American Catholic Philosophy Quarterly publishes great medieval stuff, though I see mixed views for people on how they rank. Definitely among my top 5 favorite journals, probably my favorite. (They’re also stereotyped as Thomist, which some people like and some don’t; but I wouldn’t say that characterizes all or even most medieval stuff I see in ACPQ.)

Leave a Reply