In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

I hate talking about my dissertation/research and wish it felt easier. I like my topic, but when people ask me about it, I get defensive even though people usually ask out of good will, interest, or politeness. The fact that it's somewhat upsetting for me to be asked about it makes me not want to discuss it because I don't want to accidentally be rude. I don't know if I'm just sick of my dissertation at this stage, if it feels more vulnerable because I'm more attached to the project, or if I'm overly anticipating combativeness. This even comes up when people outside of academia ask me about my dissertation. Has anyone had this experience and worked through it?

Good question. I recall struggling with this too, though I'm not sure I ever came up with a good solution other than simply practicing (very reluctantly) with grad faculty, other grad students, and later, my spouse. 

Do any readers have any helpful tips to share?

Posted in

4 responses to “Struggles talking about your dissertation?”

  1. anon

    I relate to what the OP says about feeling vulnerable while in the process of writing a dissertation. It is such a long and often lonely process where one is constantly trying out new ideas and trying to make the switch from writing as a student to writing as a professional philosopher. It is often difficult to discuss one’s dissertation because it is a work in progress and one’s ideas are likely not fully developed.
    My advice would be to practice talking about your work. I would do this very deliberately by creating 3 different “elevator pitches” that explain the main idea of your dissertation: one that is 30-60 seconds, one that is 3 minutes, and a longer explanation around 5-10 minutes. Having to distill the main argument and importance of your work is not only valuable for talking to people at conferences and in preparing for the job market, but also for clarifying your work to yourself.

  2. Agreed with anon: develop different elvator pitches at different lengths and practice them. Also, if your dissertation intersects with multiple fields/subfields, think about how you’d articulate it to people in those fields. E.g., mine was on the line between philosophy and theology, and also between hist phil and contemporary epistemology, so I had to think about how to explain my research to a theologian, an analytic philosopher, a historian of medieval philosophy, etc. I found that that challenge made me more excited about talking about my work, and the confidence that came from frequent practice decreased anxiety.

  3. grad student

    So when I talk about my research in conversation, I like to focus on the questions I’m trying to answer and grapple with, instead of the answers and my specific arguments. I think conversations are sort of hard when you are trying to convince someone of your view or ward off criticism. But conversations about questions, without set answers, are more interesting to me.

  4. Hannah

    I think it’s also important to add that you don’t have to talk about your dissertation. Sure, there are times when you do, but it’s not everyone’s business so it’s fine to not want to share. Often when I’m deep into a project I have phases where I really don’t want to talk about it (and especially with people outside academia). In these cases, I find it helpful to have up a line or two I think up in advance that allows me to gracefully turn the conversation to something I’d prefer to talk about. Since many people are asking out of good will, they will in good will follow you readily to another terrain (a good book you’re reading, an interesting lecture, questions that fascinate you about the field, observations about life, etc.).

Leave a Reply