In our newest "how can we help you?" thread, a reader asks:

I have a scenario for which I would like some advice. Let's say you're ABD, and have just a couple (just OK) publications, though with a lot of teaching experience. The remainder of your papers are still under review, and you expect one or two to wind up at more prestigious journals over the next year.

You get a TT job offer, but at a small & struggling liberal arts college, and with less than competitive compensation. You could take it and attempt to move laterally, or push your defense back a year, and use your final year of funding, going on the job market again. Is there any scenario where the latter course of action would be advisable?

This is a tough scenario, but if it were me, I'd take the TT job and try to move laterally. To me, the job-market is simply too unpredictable to pass up a TT offer. There's no guarantee you'll ever get another one, and you could spend years suffering on the market trying to get another one, especially given a "just OK" publishing record. Of course, there's also no guarantee that you'll be able to move laterally, or that the struggling college you go to won't cut your position at a later date. But at least this way you've secured something and given yourself some time in a full-time tenure-stream job (which is good experience on a CV) to find something elsewhere.

But these are just my thoughts. What are yours?

Posted in

10 responses to “Accept a TT job at a struggling college or stay in grad school?”

  1. Tenured at R1

    I would take the job in this situation. The details matter, of course. If ‘struggling’ means on the verge of actual bankruptcy and likely to shut down the entire college, then I would not. But if ‘struggling’ means strongly “tuition-dependent” and threats of (or actual) program closures (or a situation better than this), then I would take it. [that situation describes many small colleges]
    Many institutions and departments within them are more precarious than one would believe from the outside, so unless things are truly dire I would take it. Furthermore, whether right or wrong, some on search committees take candidates more seriously who are making lateral moves. Personally, I think this fails to reflect how much teaching experience candidates have these days (not to mention how well-published so many are), but I’ve witnessed others find it to be something that sets apart candidates. So getting this job will be a testament (at least to those people) that you should get another job. Again, I don’t believe this, but I have directly heard people make this sort of claim on search committees.
    An additional point: when you go back on the market, you have an obvious answer to the question “why do you want to leave your current job?”

  2. take the job (probably)

    I’m with Marcus. I would take the job and go back on the market next year. It really is the case that one might only ever get one job offer. Taking this job won’t really make you less competitive next year, as search committees will see your file and surmise what is going on in your case. And it’s generally hard to know which work situations will be good and which will be bad until one is in them, so perhaps the job is worth a shot.
    Although, I could also imagine scenarios in which declining might make sense, e.g., if you have family connections to your grad-school area, if the cost of the move is prohibitive, etc. But based on what’s said here, my advice is to take the job.

  3. grymes

    This isn’t advice, but a relevant bit of autobiography:
    I had to make this decision my first year on the market (except the choice was between an unglamorous-but-nice 1-year postdoc and the TT gig at a small& struggling liberal arts college). I “bet on myself” and turned down the TT gig. Most of my mentors–as well as the faculty at the school where I did the postdoc–were shocked by my decision. But it worked out for me, and I’m extremely grateful to my past self for making that choice. (Of course, I can’t say for sure how I would feel about it if, counterfactually, I didn’t luck out and land another (indeed, better) TT offer the next year. I think I still would have thought it was the right decision. But even I take that thought with a grain of salt–you certainly should.)
    One note: I don’t think I would have made the choice to turn down the TT offer if it weren’t for my (non-academic) partner’s lack of excitement about moving to the area the job was in. I wasn’t excited either–but I suspect I would have let the sorts of considerations in favor of taking the job that other people are giving in the comments sway me if I were single. It wasn’t so easy to rationalize away my partner’s (justified) lack of excitement.

  4. the 7 year itch

    Take the job. I had a colleague who had a friend who turned down a TT job at a four year state college (he thought he could do better!), and then spent 7 more years on the job market … finally getting a job at a four year state college. Once you have a job, you can apply for better jobs (if you still want to).

  5. doctopus

    Echoing the advice to take the job. The market is so unpredictable that there may be few to no desirable jobs in OP’s AOS next year. Also, speaking from experience on both sides of the aisle, going on the market while having stable employment is a much better experience for the applicant, simply because there is not such a growing sense of imminent doom with each rejection received.

  6. It is genuinely possible to discover (through campus visits and interviews) that you actually do not want a job that you end up being offered. But unless the scenario is something like that, the person in question should accept the position and then (if necessary or desired) go on the job market from that vantage point later.

  7. Tenured but about to be cut

    If you already know the TT job is paying badly, and you know (on top of that) the place is small and struggling financially, those are very bad signs.
    Because what this usually means, these days, is that philosophy could be cutting lines, or its major (etc.) soon; and even if those don’t happen, you will never be compensated adequately, even after promotion… (If it’s in a somewhat expensive area, or you have kids or want kids, the pay factor should matter a lot.) I (now tenured) have been dealing with all those factors, and I often wish I had just gotten no academic job and much earlier had transitioned to another career. (!)
    So while the advice even from me is probably still to take it, it’s important to raise these other concerns… Also: taking such a teaching-heavy job probably means it will be hard to keep up publishing in strong places; which will in turn make it even harder to move laterally. So you should assume that you’re taking a job you stay at (if it lasts). It’s hard to know if taking it makes you better or worse positioned to try again on the market right away, compared to coming out of grad school. But one should be realistic, that applying again may not yield anything in the future (especially if one becomes a bit more selective in where one applies).

  8. Galen

    I want to second what Tenured but about to be cut wrote. I’m tenured at a SLAC in the NYC area (Iona). I make 90% of what I started out making when you account for inflation. This is despite a tenure raise and despite my university doing reasonably well in the face of the challenges facing non-elite SLACs. Take the job or don’t, but go in with eyes open.

  9. Survivor

    I think it depends on how struggling, but in general, I would say, take the job. However, I confess that I once came back from an on-campus and I hoped they wouldn’t offer me the job because I felt like I’d have to say yes if they did and I really didn’t want that job. (The financial pressures and the terrible unpreparedness of students for academia were evident). I didn’t get the offer, but I did get a (different) VAP position, and I got a much better TT position the next year (and I am now tenured). That position I hoped I wouldn’t get is now gone; the person they hired stayed for a few years, but then the center they were hired with got replaced and so did their position.

  10. Cam

    Like others, I think you should take the job.

Leave a Reply